Agnostic.com

20 4

For all the non-whites out there, a question: Does it bother you when people inquire about your culture? Do you feel like they’re pointing out that you’re somehow different or do you welcome the opportunity to share your cultural heritage with someone who may not know much about it? EDIT: The reason I'm asking about this is that I'm having a discussion about it in another forum where someone is saying it's rude to ask others about their culture. I don't get it.

ProudMerry 7 Mar 31
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

20 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I now live in Vancouver, bc Canada but grew up in Kansas. I am white, athletic, middle class. In Vancouver I have become a minority as the majority now are asians. I regularly ask people where they are from China, Japan, Korean, Hong Kong etc. It is how the question is asked that is the difference. We spoke about this at a company sponsored event about racism where I learned how offended some people are when asked as they felt they were being called out as being different. It made them scared and uncomfortable.

0

I don't mind it when they ask. I'm half black and half Samoan, and a lot of people in my area have never seen a Samoan person. I don't think it's rude to ask at all.

Lani Level 5 Apr 10, 2018
1

Not really, it doesn't bother me. Most people who ask about culture are honestly curious.

2

Learning about other cultures can be fascinating and helps me be a more rounded and an inclusive person.

2

Why be upset when someone asks you to educate them?

Marz Level 7 Mar 31, 2018
0

Eurpopean settlement has mostly destroyed the indigenous culture here (Oz).
Many 3rd and 4th Generation "white" Aussies would have some aboriginal ancestry. I have at least 12% and am very light skinned. We are trying to re discover and preserve the indigenous culture of our country. The circles I move in are very respectful of Aboriginal heritage so the question about culture is not impolite. All pre-industrial cultures are important and of interest to me.

1

It depends on the nature of the question. If it is legitimate curiosity, I welcome it. If it's a back handed insult, that is a different matter!

1

It depends on the nature of the question. If it is legitimate curiosity, I welcome it. If it's a back handed insult, that is a di

I agree most of the time the question is pure curiosity and I do not have a problem with that. Sometimes it stems from racism and I'm white, just not native of the US

0

Great question! I’d love to hear more from the people you actually directed the question towards. There are so many methodical responses from white people below, it’s easy to miss the answers from your intended targets of the question. Is that a white thing? To offer your opinion when it wasn’t asked for? Or maybe that’s more of a male trait? I don’t know, I’m doing it right now...

1

So I'm mostly white-ish, but I have Cherokee in me, and a bit of my white is Jewish. ALL of my family, except my cousin who is half black, look strictly white, but then there's me...in the summer I look more native than my grandma, 4 some reason people especially say this when my hair is braided. So I'll try and answer from both perspectives. As a mixed heritage person, I welcome the opportunity 2 educate people about cultures outside their own, but I do think the way u approach it matters a great deal. If u ask " hey, what nationality are u?" Or " where is your family from?" I think that's great. But I have also heard "hey, u look like an Indian, didn't your people like 2 rape and scalp people?" I'll still try 2 have a civil conversation, who knows, maybe I can teach them something new. But I admit, it makes going in2 the conversation, a little difficult.

Byrd Level 7 Mar 31, 2018

@idlopalev all in all, or at least what we know ( I only know a bit of my dads side) I'm English Irish Cherokee and German (my grandpa says the Jewish kind)

1

No, why should it. There is something to be learned from the comparison and contrast bet ween cultures.

3

To answer your question, I enjoy when people ask because then I can educate them, debunk any steryotypes or confirm them. It is an opening to a conversation. A way of bonding & expanding our knowledge.

1

My family is triracial, European, Native American, and African American. I've been asked if I was Cuban, Turkish, Armenian, or had a Chinese grandmother, depending upon where I was. I mostly ignore them.

@Keyboard-Mama, Nope, people are usually idiots.

1

People hardly ever ask me about my background. They see me and just think "white". Contrary to what some on here think, I am part Italian (Father and Mother), German (Mother), Irish (Mother), and Native American (Mother). They would say I'm just a white American.

I hate cultural appropriation being some negative term used wrongly these days. Just because someone who isn't Japanese wears a kimono, it doesn't mean they are bad people.

@TheInterlooper There is cultural appreciation or cultural exchange. For something to be cultural appropriation it has to be exploitative. There is supposedly a fine line though.

1

Most people point out my resemblance to a mythological guy who delivers toys right around the winter solstice. And whole I do serve that purpose for certain family members, I do not have a North Pole cultural background. Now southern Poland, that's a different story, but the beard doesn't even register as a Polish fashion choice. ?

1

There’s nothing wrong with people asking about your cultural background. It’s something I do when meeting people all the time. I find that it is an ice breaker, a way to start conversation. Because I am a world traveler and student of other cultures in particularly language and cuisine.

1

I used to be abroad overseas a "goodwill ambassador" of the USA, I always going to be a "goodwill ambassador" of my Culture and Heritage. My Final Answer.

3

Can't say I really ever get that as a middle-class, born and raised American, eighteen years into the new millennium. The only such scenario I could imagine would be that of a foreigner asking such a question. I only speak for myself. Others may have had a different experience.

3

Define White bread. I’m of ashkenaze Jewish heritage. I don’t consider myself part of mainstream white culture or whatever that means.

4

I think a lot depends upon their demeanor and apparent purpose. If they display a genuine interest, I'm happy to discuss it -- but I'm a Jew, so rarely is their approach negative. However, I think that no matter what you are, green, orange, or purple, if their approach is friendly and at least genuine, it would be wise to oblige. Hey, who knows, you could change the course of someones life or at least increase their understanding and reduce some prejudice.

@Keyboard-Mama me too

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:47138
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.