Agnostic.com

13 12

The test of a false god; Why I am an atheist.

I was born into Christianity and indoctrinated while growing up. My extended family was extremely religious as well, we even had a few preachers. I grew up in the First United Methodist church, my sect was particularly literalist, they believe that all scripture was inspired by god. They believe that Satan was actively doing harm in our world and we were involved in spiritual battles constantly.

I wanted to become a preacher, more specifically a teacher of gods word. I realized that different Christian religions believed many different things. For example: In some churches females were not allowed to be in leadership. In others lesbians could be preachers. (Not at my church). They all were interpreting the Bible different and stood fast by differing beliefs. They all could not be right. Either God wanted lesbian preachers or forbid the practice as he hated lesbians and women could not be leaders in the church. It could not be both ways. This was just one of many differences in churches that god could only have one opinion on.
I did not care about what man said, the church said or even preachers. I wanted to follow god and do what god wanted. I could not bring myself to teach as I knew I could be wrong about what I believed as no one could agree what gods word actually was. I decided to delay going to seminary as I knew that I would learn mans differing beliefs from a given sect and not necessarily what god wanted. I needed to be alone with god and study the bible myself without the churches bias. I prayed to god to give me clarity so that I could move forward and serve him the way HE wanted, not how I thought he might want.

I had been taught not to investigate or study anything that was secular. Secular meant anything that was not godly. I had been taught that everything is either with god or against it. They also taught me that god was all powerful and would protect me. I was such a hard core believing young man that I did not care or worry that secular information would possibly corrupt me. God would be there to guide me as they promised.
At first I noticed inconsistencies in my bible studies. I found that the Bible Said all sins are forgiven and that blasphemy was unforgiveable. It could not be both ways. I found there was a reason that people had many different beliefs about the Bible. It said many contradictory things and many could not be reconciled. I again had to know why and what god intended.

I started by praying constantly and studying the Bible intensely. I honestly don’t know how many times I read it straight through or how many years I put into more traditional studies. I also began to study history(my favorite), literature, languages, geology, cosmology, anthropology, archeology, statistics, philosophy, etc. Anything that related to Biblical studies including writings from Biblical scholars both secular and Christians. I spent two years just studying the apocrypha and the gnostic gospels trying to find answers.

This led to what I call the test of a false god.

I began to question how was my god any different from any other god. As many different types of gods were described in the ancient Christian writings. There were many false gods out there (that being any god that was not mine). So I asked myself how would one differentiate between a real god and a false god? So what would a real god look like? Many gods are unknowable or unperceivable. Oddly enough if that is the case how could anyone tell me about an unperceivable god? How would they know? None the less an unperceivable god can not be proven to exist by definition. So it would be impossible to define or prove that any god existed even if I just made it up. One can not prove that they exist.
So what qualities would a god that does not exist have?

They can't work miracles.

They don’t answer prayers.

They can not be perceived.

Most of all it struck me that a god that was not real required faith to believe in them.
All gods required faith!
So how did my god stack up against a false god?

My god did not work miracles. There were claims that were no better than other religions without any evidence.
My god did not answer prayers. There again were claims that were no better than other religions without any evidence. There was certainly no obvious things like limbs being regenerated.
My god could not be perceived. He was unknowable.
But most of all, My god required faith to believe in it. In fact believing through faith was the ONLY requirement!

Then I realized that my god was no more valid than what I knew to be a false or made up god.

When I realized this it was real hard to believe that there was any real god. Even it there was a god it did not care enough to be actively involved in the world as said god was not relevant and there was no reason for me to care about the god either. In which case a god that does not do god stuff is not a god.

When It came down to understanding that my god was no more valid than a god that was not real I simply could no longer believe.

This is the first time I have publocally spoken about The test of a false god. Let me know what you think of the concept. Thank You!

DavidLaDeau 8 Apr 30
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

13 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

2

You've faced the power of indoctrination and come out on the other side. For that I congratulate you. It's not an easy journey, particularly when your family and friends are staunch believers.

My family is zelots just as I was. Unfortinately I don't have contact with them with the exception of one cousin. Ironically we met on line. I hope to meet him in person!

@DavidLaDeau Hope it works out. Family is important.

0

Yep Yep Yep

you tube "Pray to the Milk Jug"

It was not done by me I just stumbled across it one day.

1

It is so cruel for children to have this rubbish forced on them. Your journey and your continued questioning was amazing to read. You are in this community of God zombies but somehow think logically and find your way out. You must have felt so let down and felt you had wasted your life by the end but to me I can't help but feel amazed that you even started to cut through the fog, let alone fought yourself completely free. I take my hat off to your clarity of thought in difficult circumstances. I doubt many could do it.

I did not care about anything but knowing how to be the best Christian I could. I wanted to KNOW I was doing what god wanted. I wanted to know the "truth".

The Bible says the truth shallmset you free. It did from religion.

Actually I sometimes wish I did not know the truth. It would be easier to live the lie. Yes I was devistated by reality when I discovered it. Everything I grew up to believe, my entire worldview was shattered. It took my many years (mabe a decade) after I knew that Imdid not believe in god before I could say it aloud even alone with no witnessess.

@DavidLaDeau You were strongly conditioned from childhood. This will cause you grief at the loss of trust and despair at the loss of your world view which had been an important part of you. Atheism can feel like a harsh reality at first (It was for me but I was young) but over time it becomes incredibly soothing and a comfort. Is it the fact that we don't effectively live forever that you are still finding difficult or is it something else?

@afrogonalog My entire world view was a lie. I had guilt for having sexual urges...very vannila sexual acts werre dirty for example. But it was bullshit. I was finally free but my world veiw was wrong. I still have not fully recovered from irrational thinking, such as black and white thinking.

1

Wow, that was really long lol 😂 but fantastic. Thank you for sharing with us, I also have some similar experiences as you and I am glad to discover truth.

Actually I try my best to keep post as short as possible as readers (including myself) tend to loose interest in long post. In this case it was necessary.

@DavidLaDeau I agree with you and indeed it is your reality and someone could read it and it would mean a big difference to them. It was great 👌🏻

0

A difficult journey of trying ro reconcile your beliefs with what made sense to you, not too dissimilar to mine without the whole seminary thing. How free did you actually feel when you thought to yourself, there is no god, or at least not one that gives a damn about humanity as anything special? For me it was a great sense of freedom and then only a small step to, there is no god at all and no need to believe in the idea of soul etc.

Actually I am just beginning to experience the freedom over the last 5 years once I came out. The huge feeling I had was disappointment. I had invested my life in a lie.

1

Fell asleep after the second zzzzzzzzzz!

I am glad I could help.

3

Like many sane people, you are allergic to logical fallacies, in this case the logical fallacy of special pleading (for one particular god).

3

The Christian faith in which I was raised doesn't even acknowledge the existence of other deities, which meant that there were no false gods. In fact, no false vs. real God argument was ever even considered. However, it was my own experience as a parent that doomed my faith in this 'one and only' deity, as I could no longer tolerate the 'bad parenting' going on.

If you're a halfway honest person, you pretty much have to conclude that this God, as described in the Bible (and even as he supposedly exists today), is a fucking loser as a Dad. In fact, this "God" is one helluva vile and twisted monster who deserves nothing more than our loathing and contempt, and to be brought up on child abandonment, endangerment, abuse and infanticide by some form of celestial child protective services! So, once I renounced my faith in this God, and walked away from my church, there was (thankfully) no other deity to turn to. Game over, man ... game over!

I am reminded of Exodus 20:3 "Thou shalt have no other gods before me" (KJV).

@anglophone Agreed. Seems fairly cut and dried, doesn't it? But the explanation given by the faith in which I was raised is that the 'false gods' were never gods at all, but rather caricatures or idols of beings that never existed. In other words, from Baal to the present, the idolaters only thought they were worshiping another god. However, since no other gods exist, they were only worshiping something that was never there--an inaminate object or idol.

@p-nullifidian Thank you for giving me that background. Talk about mental gymnastics ...

@anglophone Tis the path that many, if not most monotheists must travel. To even consider the possibility that other gods ever, for one moment, existed is to open a pandora's box of the inexplicable. Most Christians never even consider the possibility of a 'competing' deity. As has been frequently observed, Christians are 'atheists' regarding all deities but the 'one.'

@p-nullifidian Honestly I never considered that there might be another god. As as a result of the test of faith I never did after accepting that my god was not real either.

@Novelty Very Nice interpretation!

3

The only conclusion I have been able to come to about god(s) from observing reality and how the universe and nature works is that there is no god(s), real or imagined, true or false.

2

Congratulations, you found Deism and took a left. The Deity, in Deism, doesn't care whether you, I, or anything else thinks it's there. Gives the Deity no interest whatsoever. THAT Deity cares only about watching the art unfold and we were a bi-product of other chemical interactions so merely another aspect of the art. I think that Deity might, in fact, exist. There's no way to know so there's no point in dwelling long on the question. We won't be penalized for getting it wrong. Probably won't ever know if we do or don't. As Zen teaches, it just is. I can't imagine this Deity wouldn't be pleased that something which can admire Thou's art, along with Thou, did come along.

I was a diest for a short period of time until I discovered that my christian god according to the Bible COULD NOT exist. I found not only that my god was no more valid than a false god but neither were any others!

@JohnnyQB Read it again. I don't imply any such knowledge of what Thou thinks if Thou exists. Deism is a religion (see Age Of Reason) and I wrote in that context.

Yes, my avatar was a Deist, as were a good number of his contemporaries, but now that we can account for 13.7 billion years of physics, one might as well accept "Big Bangism," as opposed to Deism, from a practical matter at least.

@p-nullifidian I'd agree but being able to say that I believe in A God also gives me the honest reply of "God's Will" when theists whine about this or that calamity. I think that's funny. As for whether it's really there or not IDC (unless it's flying a UFO).

@JohnnyQB Key word is "May." IDK, nor care, if it does or not but this is a sight for people other than atheists. As for what you know of, I'm not writing only for you. Again, there are others who may read it.

@JohnnyQB I was indoctrinated from birth, I was brainwashed and had no choice. That being said if I understand you correctly don't lean toward a dieity. I simply respond to the claim their is one or many.

@JohnnyQB My bad!

@DavidLaDeau It's that attitude coming through in text that I responded to. Not that first time I've had that reaction to JQB but he undoubtedly means well. Shrug.

@JohnnyQB I'm a Tao Zenist. I've had a varied spiritual background and am only now beginning to reincorporate Deism. I think the only way to fight religion is through being a believer. That's because, when they throw the experience thing at me, I can say that I have a personal relationship to my God. Deism doesn't require me to do anything with it so what's the harm in a small fib? It also allows me to tell God to get fucked and feel Thou is amused by my audacity.

@SeaGreenEyez It's important to an end to dangerous and deadly myths. Shake your head all you want but you're wrong. smh

@SeaGreenEyez

@SeaGreenEyez I don't care what you like or for cats.

5

You shared a lot but I'm struck by something: You are using a logical, rational, scientific approach to try and understand a made-up story. People believe because they've been taught to. It is not rational. No more so than a fairy tale.

Good luck.

6

I notice that a lot of people who end up leaving religion and are most passionate about their decision and their work on this topic are people who wanted to teach religion. They've been taught that those beliefs were so good that people used their humanism to then try to spread those beliefs onto others: only to realize later that not everything they were told was the truth. Glad to see that you shared this.

5

If the real thing and the fake thing are indistiguishable from each other, it does make you wonder why anyone believes it to begin with.

One notion I've been considering lately is the inverse of the intelligent design idea. Maybe it was just my personality, but I never saw nature or reality as anything but devoid of intelligence (or any overall "intention" or agency). Even when I was very young and believed in some kind of god, I didn't see his creative fingerprints on trees, people, animals, life, the stars, etc. Everything was too messy, too unpredictable. I might be intelligent, but that intelligence isn't magic, and requires a collection of things, none of which are intelligent either.

Maybe the "stupid design" idea isn't exactly what I mean, but it's close. I don't project intelligence, agency, etc., into the trees, rocks, water, etc. It all seems utterly unintelligent and uncreated to me, even at face value, and it always did. (I do remember at around 3 years old thinking the hills around our town looked like a giant must have thrown a huge blanket down to form the hills, because that's what they looked like. But around age 4 of 5, whenever I looked at them...they were just hills.

It's not about things being intelligent. Their life derived from something adapting to its environment and seeked out more of that something to keep existence going. That wasn't brainy but reactive. The amazing part is that it also indicates an awareness. That seems brainy but it only means intention to gain the needed something and reproduce. Once those things are secured then awareness turns to security from harm. It really doesn't need to progress beyond that for most organisms (including us).

@rainmanjr I understand all of that very well. It's just that religious folks tend to layer an extra magical element onto awareness or intelligence or intentionality that just isn't there, so whenever anyone says "intelligence" or "awareness", they read it as if everyone understands it is intrinsically supernatural--in a similar way to how I thought the hills had to have been put their by a giant who had a giant blanket, because that's the immediate impression I got every time I looked at them (at 3 years old). I had a discussion in college one time when we read Descarte in regard to "I think, therefore I am". A couple students claimed this meant the soul existed, but it wasn't compelling to me at all. You might as well say, "I am, therefore I am", or as that book in the '90s might have put it, "I feel, therefore I am," as we discovered more and more that thoughts and feelings are intertwined in ways we never suspected. But after we die, we do no thinking, feeling, or being. We can't even SAY, "I am, therefore I am," which seems to put a pin in the whole notion. (Descarte was probably using it as a foundation of knowledge in any case, claiming that we might doubt anything except our own existence as that is necessary to doubt anything at all. I'm still not sure I even buy THAT.)

Intelligent Design? You mean....my House? My toaster? My truck ?
I agree: what I see in nature is a tangled, overgrown friggin' mess.
The Natural World is Beautiful, wonderful, intoxicating but TOTALLY Devoid of design

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:490918
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.