Agnostic.com

11 1

Do you "count" the childhood indoctrination you've experienced but later became an atheist? Could you say you believed in God or were Christian when it was briefly all you knew? Or would you say you've always been atheist?

Virgoan 5 Apr 12
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

11 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

I don't count the time that I believed in the Easter Bunny and Santa Clause... because, as soon as I was old enough to figure it out I realized it was bull$h¡+.

I don't go around telling people I am a recovering from hyper-materialism mixed with touches of European mythology.

1

My family was sort of religious and I went to church some as a child. I got more into Christianity in college and in my 20's. I went to a protestant-affiliated college and was active in religious organizations. In grad school I got invoved in a charismatic group but I was kicked out because I believed in evolution. When I married and had kids, my husband and I were still attending church but we found it hard to find one that fit. We tried a Unitarian church for awhile but it tried to be everything to everyone - Christian,Jewish, pagan,wiccan etc. so it didn't feel right either. I began to have more doubt, as did my husband, but one of our children started going to a church that her friends went to. We tried going there because she wanted us to, even though it was conservative. The last straw for me came the Sunday after 9/11. The minister said in his sermon that there were a lot of people in hell that had died in the attack because they weren't "saved". That pushed me over the atheist edge.

1

When I was young I went to every church in my town. I had to check them all out, or I had friends that went there. I tried Sunday school, I prayed, I believed the bible stories... Then I lived with an ex nun and an ex priest and their three children. I was 16 at the time and billeted with them as I was from out of town and moved there to train as a competitive athlete. I was also starting to deal with depression and the fear of being gay... They taught me that being gay was a sickness... They also wanted me to become Catholic because I had never been baptised. I lived with them for two years, and those two years scarred me for life. I contacted one of the children later in life to ask if her parents still thought that homosexualaity was a sickness. She told me that their thoughts were slowly evolving with the times and wished me well... I never really thought much about religion for many years after that. I travelled around the world and saw many religions being practiced. I saw opulent churches, synagogues and temples, next door to poverty and begging. In my 30's I officially came out as an athiest. It all seems so ridiculous to me now. I do love the art and architecture of religion but that is all.

1

I never really thought about it much until I was an adult. My parents were married in the Catholic church and I was baptized,but that was the extent of religion in my upbringing. The only time we went into a church together were for weddings and funerals, and we never talked about religion. I really never cared if there were or weren't a god, honestly.

1

I never believed, even in the indoctrination camps of my childhood.

1

I have only ever been an atheist, because of being in an atheist family,

I think we are all different in terms of how much we take in information I know that as a child my family lied to me so much I never believed any of them, either so i think it rather depends upon the persuasiveness of the church sunday school teacher and he willingness of the child to take in the story

2

I was indoctrinated by my parent's insistance into Reform Judaism. Forced to go to 10 miserable years of Sunday School I managed to avoid Hebrew School which I later regretted. I was ostracized by my fellow classmates and not invited to any of their Bar/Bat Mitzvahs, a social event. I was one of three kids who got up and denounced god at our confirmation from Sunday School, a big deal to our families. Angry and humiliated my parents punished me by shipping me on a Bible Study tour for the summer.

Wow that's quite a story... You are a brave soul...

4

As a child I didn't know any better. Eventually unanswered prayers and asking simple questions lead me to atheism. It stopped making sense and just started to really seem foolish.

I don't see the need to shy away from that fact. It's because of my religious upbringing that I have the knowledge of religion that I have. It's because of this knowledge that I fell from religion. It's because of this knowledge that I remain atheist.

KDzo Level 4 Apr 12, 2018

That is my response too.

1

I don't think I ever truly believed in a god. I was always skeptical and questioned everything at church.

2

Even as a child, being raised in the catholic church, before I even heard the word 'atheist' or knew what it meant, I knew it (religion) was all bullshit.
When I finally knew what atheism meant, I was so relieved and embraced it immediately.
Even if I couldn't be "out" about it early on, I knew I didn't believe.

3

My parents tried, I remember that much. But I believe I was pretty open about calling BS before I even stopped the whole Santa thing. That’s my earliest religious based memory of arguing.
Christian neighbor kid who was a few years older than I was told me there was no Santa.
So I told him the was no Jesus.
He cried. I laughed. I got grounded. He went to church more. Now he’s a pastor and we’re friends again. Haha.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:56156
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.