Agnostic.com

12 5

The small orchestra that I play in has just begun a series of Xmas concerts for the local community. We play the usual Xmas carols plus a number of modern Xman songs. Despite being a non Christian and non any religion I enjoy playing in these concerts with all the nonsense red and green 'dress ups' that we deck ourselves up in. I play Recorder/Oboe and Clarinet in these . I enjoy the companionship of my fellow musicians. Interestingly there are no evangelist Christians pushing their beliefs onto others in the community that I move about in. We do have a minister who gives a Xmas message during these concerts but I find this boring and just something to sit through. And we have Santa turn up in a fire brigade truck at the end of the concerts. I love seeing the joy on the faces of the toddlers when he turns up handing out sweets. It's an old time honoured nonsense tradition that is a wonderful family gathering.

Skyfacer 7 Dec 4
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

12 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

If it doesn't bother you, it sure isn't going to bother me. Enjoy!

gearl Level 8 Dec 5, 2017
1

A true lover of humanity. It's not all about you. There's love and charity from you. I don't criticize those who don't follow our path. Some of them find a way to move in our direction. There's a freedom of not being pressured by those false beliefs and our head starting to clear up. It's an awesome experience. Hopefully they will find their way to the truth. Meanwhile, love the innocent and those that are confused. When they find out what we believe and see how we live our lives, they will not back away because we've hurt them or they fear us.. love you brother.

1

have fun and play Little Drummer Boy for me

1

I have little trouble with certain songs of the season as many of the tunes (I listen to instrumentals, not voice) were lifted by christians, originally not being religiously intended at all. Most of the old breton carols and celtic songs of the season are not religious, even in lyric. And... there's always the Nutcracker.

Zster Level 8 Dec 4, 2017
1

There's so much music I've been a part of, that was "religious" in nature. But the music was good (like Handel's Messiah, for instance, or many Bach pieces), and even though I sang some words I definitely did not believe, I enjoyed both the singing and the awesome sounds we made !

Doesn't mean any of it is gonna infiltrate the non-believing musicians ! Ha.

2

The main thing is you get fulfilled and are happy in participating,that’s all that really counts.

2

My girls are now in their 20s and 30s-when they were younger they took place in holiday school concerts-I'm ok with generic x-mas songs.

4

I see nothing wrong with Xmas celebrations despite more than 50 years of atheism. the music is beautiful and the tradition can increase the sense of community. You don't need to feel guilty for having a good at a party regardless whether you believe in the reason for the party or not.
The longest night and the coldest time of the year will always inspire people to come together whether we through Xmas away or not.

4

To me, the higher is sharing joyfully in this thing called life, no matter how it is interpreted.

Tomm Level 5 Dec 4, 2017
3

I often play by-request piano bar sing-alongs, and I have three scheduled so far this month, at which I'll definitely be playing Christmas/holiday/seasonal songs. I'll play whatever anyone wants me to play. My boycotting their favored songs isn't going to change anything, it just creates disconnect, and I think compassion and connection are among the things most needed in this world. Not to mention, even I personally am moved by many religious songs, even if just because of their music rather than the lyrics. I think militant judgment is as unseemly in atheists/agnostics/etc. as it is in religious people.

5

No need to through out the Bach with the bathwater. I too, a devout atheist, enjoy the hundreds of years of music written for the season.

Yes GambaBabe. As false as the world view that Christianity has, the belief system has certainly been the catalyist for some wonderful music over the recent centuries. One just has to ignore the words and enjoy the music for it's own sake.

0

I do not understand any of this except joy in being with fellow musicians. Can’t you find another way to make toddlers smile? Maybe just giving them sweets (which will degrade teeth and health but what the heck) is enough to accomplish this apparently magical feat?
I have a musician friend who enjoys it but plays for money. That I understand. One fools themselves into enjoying what we do for money. To put up with Christian hymns for the sake of fun would not be possible for me.

I maintain that good music is good music, and some of the best has come from people writing for the Summer Solstice celebration. I don't agree with the words, so I get orchestral renditions which I enjoy immensely. Mannheim Steamroller being one of my favorites.

Hi Rainmanjr. I certainly agree with the degrading teeth comment πŸ™‚

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:6601
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.