Agnostic.com

81 5

What are your views on polygamy?

Redcupcoffee 7 Jan 30
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

81 comments (26 - 50)

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I'm all for it. I'd just have to start buying vitamins in bulk

0

If you are that good at multitasking who is anyone to judge?

0

I remember hearing a song by an African who had some experience with this. He sang "Polygamy is not for everybody". I imagine it could only work out with committed people. Seems like the women involved would be only getting a share of the man's attention. That might not be a good thing.

2

I've said it before.. nope! I have enough trouble satisfying one person in a relationship. If I want to disappoint two people, I'll just go have dinner with my parents.

Duke Level 8 Jan 30, 2018
1

I think it might be the most perfect arrangement - it maximizes stability for the woman, and gives men the freedom and flexibility they are more wired to desire. I think jealousy is a toxic, controlling emotion that we should work to dismantle, and monogamy is rooted in puritanism which is antiquated and needs to go. Studies show the US in particular is more sexually uptight than other cultures, and I think that leads to a lot of repression, mental problems and violence.

Thank you...it's something I've really struggled to square with and put a lot of thought into. Every woman I've met seems to be a hardcore monogamist, while I'm waking up to the idea I have more poly inclinations.

1

Polyamory is not about the sick cult of not Mormons called Fundamentalist Latter Day Saints still headed by convicted felon Warren Jeffs. He and many of his followers are sick disgusting, brain-washing pedophiles or enablers of same. What they practice is a twisted and sick version of Polygamy.

Kids get molested by their family members in monogamous relationships ALL THE TIME.

On POLYAMORY -- it is doubtful that a child with polyamorous parents are any more likely to be molested than children of monogamous parents.

1

It's not for me but more power to those it is.

2

It really doesn't matter to me what other adults do within their own relationships, as long as everyone is consenting. That said, I think most of us have enough trouble navigating singular relationships as it is. Adding additional people just seems like asking for trouble.
But hey, knock yourselves out.

1

I have been in a rewarding relationship with one woman for a long time. It has been enough for me. However, what others do is their business as long as no one is being damaged by it. Whatever rocks your boat, kids.

0

Riskier to contract and spread STDs. ....confusing for children of the several parents half siblings ...Daddys called "uncles" Aunts called mommies. ...DNA tests necessary to confirm paternity with polygamous moms. ...enables patriarchal male entitlement by women agreeing to this emotional minefield. ...my Uncle was a bigamist but never arrested in Paris or Des Moines. ....I HAVE Atheist cousins from his marriages so I am partly grateful. ...he "married" Korean girl very late in life she a teen he in his '70's. ...she inherited his fortune not his 4 sons or 1st 2 widows he's buried @Pearl Harbor one of many Sailors I'm my Navy tradition

1

As long as people are ok in the marriage and are of legal age, no problem.

However lots of abuse are hiding in polygamy as related to church.

1

I view any man who is a polygamist as also a masochist. 🙂

0

I don't mind short people myself. I mean im not perfect as im dylsexic.

0

Is it a proposition that you are considering or are you considering it as a lifestyle choice? IMHO I am finding that as time goes on, people are less inclined to criticise you for your lifestyle choices.

3

Polygamy is cultural, whether abhorred (here in the U.S.) or culturally required (Tibet). My personal view is that a family is a group the joins together for richer, for poorer (etc. etc.). If it works, and no one is harmed? All the power to them.

1

Is a chance for a man to disappoint many women at same time 😛

or many women with headaches fucking moaning lol

@LeighShelton boo hoo

lol

0

feels like Ralphie wearing all them coats in A Xmas Story.

0

What is your opinion? I do not think it works well in majority of relationship. Most men and women are possessive and will definitely not like sharing their partners. But you can always fall for someone whether you are married or not. That is more like an accidental relationship. By that I mean you do not plan for that relationship. So if you are already married and you get attracted to or start to have feelings toward someone, will that qualify polygamous even if the two person do not make it open to each other about their feelings.

What you describe sounds like an affair -- cheating

Polyamory is very different from what we all know as polygamy as typically practiced by Mormons.

In polyamory EVERYBODY who is in that poly relationship is open, honest, forthright, in view of all, not hiding, not sneaking, not lying, utilizing their own relationship rules regarding dating, sex, affection, household maintenance, etc. etc. which have been discussed extensively before taking the dive into opening up the relationship for multiple loves.

1

Not my cuppa tea.

1

I only want to date one person at a time.

Same here

0

My only concern about it that - it often appears to be a way for powerful religious (male) leaders to control & subjugate women & younger men within the power structure of their 'church'.

Otherwise - as others have said here - as long as they are all willing, of sound mind & have a choice to leave if they want to I don't see it as my business to judge.

Your two paragraphs are precisely the difference between polygamy and polyamory.

Your top paragraph describes polygamy. Your bottom paragraph describes polyamory.

@BlueWave I see absolute zero difference between several love partners and several marriage partners. ....the law does not provide a loophole for "intent" when children ADOPTED FOSTER STEP or BIRTH arrive into these POLY lives they also cannot fully embrace intentions nor deserve the evil religions imposed by anyone

THE PROFESSOR AND HIS WONDER WOMEN movie is a true story of polyamory FREE LOVE 1930's until the last son died last year making the movie about his 3 parents

2

I have always been monogamous, but as I get older, and with this question posed, I don’t know that I would be completely against POLYAMORY (not polygamy) without facing the possibility and giving it considerable thought.

5

My fantasy relationship has always included myself and 2 bi-sexual men. As an actual long-term/life partnership, not just a drunken night of debauchery that is sure to get back to my mom. (And to clarify this Forever Threesome does not at anytime involve DP. Thank you!!!!!)
Could I do it in reality? I strongly doubt it. I can barely hold onto one man. And I've noticed most our male poly community around here has long hair. Not my bag. In fact, in this reoccurring fantasy, both my lovers look exactly like Dolph Lundgren. (To clarify, this is not an incestuos brother thing either, it's just an odd coincidence!!!!)
But I do know there is only one ounce of lesbian in me and it is reserved for Shannon Doherty.
So.... I try not to concern myself in other's love affairs. Well, from a "morally superior" stance. If you've got video tapes to share, I'll grab the popcorn.

That was freaking hilarious, Alicia! 🙂 🙂

1

Why do guy's want acceptance to legally fool around? I see no love in this kind of relationship. Just lust and control.

@irascible Me too. Still am.

@irascible. Ok... I read the question as do I support a guy with more then one wife. Or a women with sister wives.... my answer is no.

@BlueWave
Polygamy (from Late Greek ?????????, polygamía, "state of marriage to many spouses" )[1][2][3][4] is the practice of marrying multiple spouses. When a man is married to more than one wife at a time, sociologists call this polygyny. When a woman is married to more than one husband at a time, it is called polyandry. If a marriage includes multiple husbands and wives, it can be called a group marriage.

In contrast, monogamy is marriage consisting of only two parties. Like "monogamy", the term "polygamy" is often used in a de facto sense, applied regardless of whether the state recognises the relationship.[n 1] In sociobiology and zoology, researchers use polygamy in a broad sense to mean any form of multiple mating.

Worldwide, different societies variously encourage, accept or outlaw polygamy. Of societies which allow or tolerate polygamy, in the vast majority of cases the form accepted in polygyny. According to the Ethnographic Atlas (1998), of 1,231 societies noted, 588 had frequent polygyny, 453 had occasional polygyny, 186 were monogamous and 4 had polyandry;[5] although more recent research suggests polyandry may be more common than previously thought.[6] From a religious point of view, in contemporary society polygyny is associated with the Muslim religion, although not all Muslim cultures practice it, and neither is it restricted to this religion. In cultures which practice polygamy, its prevalence among that population is often connected to class and socioeconomic status.[7]

From a legal point of view, in many countries, although marriage is legally monogamous (a person can only have one spouse, and bigamy is illegal), adultery is not illegal, leading to a situation of de facto polygamy being allowed, although without legal recognition for non-official "spouses".

According to scientific studies, the human mating system is considered to be moderately polygynous, based on both surveys of world populations,[8][9] and on characteristics of human reproductive physiology.[10][11][12]

Forms

@BucketlistBob When I answered the question, I swear I read it to say polyamory. Now I read it again and it says polygamy. That explains my response here, which I deleted. 🙂

@BlueWave. I want to be your friend. I'm not fussing... thank you for not getting mad....

0

I worked with a guy who had four live in partners. It seemed to work for him. That being said, there are numerous cases in which polygamy involved minors, incest and domination.

There are TENS, if not HUNDREDS of THOUSANDS more cases every years in which monogamy involved minors, incest and domination, right?

@BlueWave Yah. I would think so. I was specifically thinking of the "old school" Mormon sects in rural Utah. The LDS church has now officially banned polygamy. However, in these old sects the wifes are often under age, are just expected to marry certain men and not given a choice, and are expected to be subservient. It is, or at least was, a bit of a stand off between authorities and human services Vs these Mormon sects.

@Rudy1962 Yep, the FLDS under Warren Jeffs and his ilk. Repugnant.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:19561
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.