Agnostic.com

39 2

Do you believe Chiropractors are effective?

  • 34 votes
  • 37 votes
kgoodyear 6 Dec 25
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

39 comments (26 - 39)

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

I went to one who scared the HELL out of me, cracking my neck! Then, I found the one I see now and she's just wonderful! I have an old whiplash injury which still gives me fits, and probably always will. She really helps with that. Yes...there's some "woo woo" in the office but I ignore it.

1

I have friends that swear by them, but I think that it's faulty science.

1

Yes. A chiropractor treated both the painful symptoms and the cause of my stenosis. Traditional medical doctors wanted to start with steroids leading to eventual surgery, with no guarantees. If you are seeking a chiropractor, do your research. Find one with experience treating your specific ailment. Get references. Just like traditional medical doctors, some are better than others.

1

Absolute bunk. Do know anyone who was cured of anything by a chiropractor?

JimG Level 8 Dec 25, 2018

Yes. My chiropractor got rid of my spinal pains.

@maturin1919 I'm telling the truth. My spine was hurting. I went to the chiropractor. He did his job. My spine stopped hurting. Something was out of place, and he put it back where it belonged.

Same here...help me with my sciatic, as well as SOME of my other joint problems. Not all, but did help some, and much preferred over popping pills or cutting me open.

@BestWithoutGods I have to agree with @John_Tyrell "What they do right can be done by a registered massage therapist at lower cost.

Anything else is pseudo-science."

They've helped me. I fell about 12 feet and landed on concrete which messed up my pelvis. It migrates out of place occasionally and causes my back to hurt. Chiro care can fix it.

0

I grew up as the daughter of a chiropractor and there was definitely an anti-medical bias in our house. That said, I think there was some benefit in embracing a less medicalized world view. Personally, for occasional back pains as an adult, I’ve found massage to be more helpful.

CeeFi Level 3 Dec 29, 2018
0

Chiropractory is not based on religion. Its based on understanding the bodies alignments and putting various vertebrae back in alignment. If you find a chiropractor that is woo woo, that him/her not the practice. Its a lot like be a mechanic and having two gears gett out of alignment or timing.

we aren't machines. why do people try to equate it to machines. I mean, it is what it is and that is "air" in a joint and the bones hitting each other, They aren't aligning anything they are quacks.

@kgoodyear.

Seems like you had your mind up before you asked the question. Never said we were machines. I just offered an analogy. Dont like the analogy, ignore it. Ive used them and I found relief. Im not a fool or uneducated, so do not presume to condescend, we're in the same age bracket.

@t1nick Of course I had my opinion before I even posted this. I was just testing my own assertions to see if they were right.

0

Hey remember Alan on "2 and a half men" was a chiropractor and they nailed it on the show.

0

Being so sick myself, I can tell you what works for me, does NOT work for others, and vice versa. I take my health as a project that I am managing - with best outcomes for all.

0

I’ve had good luck with chiropractic for my back for 20 years but I draw the line at my spine. When they try going into other areas I’m fairly skeptical. One was going to cure me with yogurt. Dude, you aren’t going to cure me with yogurt. A stretching thing called Rossiter has worked for me too. It was a bit paunful but got the job done.

0

I have had no experience with any.
However, my late grandmother saw one nearly 40 years ago, and he helped her
to walk upright again.

0

Used to be okay. Not so much anymore.

0

I have seen it work in specific applications. Other times, no. So the question is too general even though I answered yes.

0

i have friends who swear by them. i have been to a few and none ever helped me a bit. one molested me. i do not blame chiropractics for the molester but whatever good that field may offer it has never offered me.

g

0

I have a relative whose chiropractic speciality is adjusting the plates in the skulls of newborn infants.

I see an ortho/PT for my bulging discs. I've been pain free since May 2008. The PTs taught me tricks to self align as at every visit my spine was out of alignment.

Zster Level 8 Dec 25, 2018

just curious, was there something wrong with the "plates" in the baby's head?

I'm sorry...adjusting the plates in the skulls of newborns? I cannot imagine any sane parent allowing such an insane thing.

@kgoodyear I know none of the specifics. Googling "cranial plate misalignment" pulls ip a lot, though...

[ncahf.org]

And specifically regarding babies:
[smartparents.sg]

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:252123
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.