Agnostic.com

57 2

Why did your marriage fail?

Redcupcoffee 7 Mar 17
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

57 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

4

Don't get married.

@Donotbelieve ?

4

1st marriage - I left an alcoholic and an abuser after 16 years.
2nd marriage-Alcohol abuse, PTSD issues never resolved. Only 2 years.

Yikes

3

Not officially married but commited to a monogamous live together relationship for 15 years. Failed because I asked him to stop sucking me financially dry. I suddenly became the bitchy one, do your share, be responsible. Thank goodness I did not legally marry him, he'd run up $13,000 in credit card debt I knew nothing about. Missed the sex but not the stress of the failing relationship.LOL

Another like but not like.
I have been thinking of this issue lately. If one, who is financially secure, gets together with another who has little money does one, in essence, buy the other?
BTW did you see the street sign I posted?

@JackPedigo NO I did not see the street sign, I looked on your page under posts. was it funny?

@JackPedigo Money was not an issue when we started out. He up graded the house I owned and he did alot of work on the 10 acres of raw land I had in eastern wa but as I transitioned from union scale wages in the printing industry to potter/artist income during the last 3 years of the relationship I could see he was not willing to be a real partner like he claimed he wanted. People do change as you know.

@MrLizard There basically are two things that ruin a relationship - money or sex. Couples change and things can start out good but go south for whatever reason.

@silverotter11 The one thing my parents argued about was money. She married at 17 and still living at home. He expected her to manage the finances. People wrongly assume everyone has money management genes. It was just a good thing this was before credit cards.

We kids realized we had to learn about this and we did. Money was a bit of an issue in 2 of my relationships but both partners knew/cared little about money and I managed it but with their full knowledge. My first wife wanted to buy a house (in Bakersfield - no way) so I convinced her we could save the money and buy with cash. The first year we had $10K. When she divorced me I knew how little she cared about money and offered her $500. She said she wanted more $600 (she thought we had $1,000 and she was getting the best of me)! The issue was she had run off with a naval officer (and took our daughter). He was eventually kicked out of the service for this but found a job making close to $100K (this was 1984) so I did not feel bad. My second partner got her JD after we split. A few years later the calls started. The calls were from collection agencies looking for her. Even after we moved to Lopez I got a call!

I think a relationship should be based on emotional, mental, physical and fiscal compatibility. I would hope that in our 'stage of life' most of the changes have happened.

@MrLizard It is about why a relationship failed and a lack of sharing is one grounds. At a certain stage, that includes finances. When one has a house and money and meets another without those things there can be no sharing in this area. This is not fair for either party and will lead to bad feelings.

@MrLizard Isn't it a bummer when the sex is so good?? My ex actually came to resent the fact I had that much 'control' over him. In my dreams I wish I had that much powere, lol. It is complicated and I think that resentment may had led more to the abuse and money thing in the end. But by then I was so done with his bullshit I was glad he left.

0

Which one?

4

There isn't enough server space for all the reasons why my marriage failed.

lol

0

There were many reasons. Let's start with the letter, A. Adultery, Alcoholism, Abuse (mental, emotional, physical and financial). There have to be some strongly compelling reasons for a conservative female family court judge to award custody of a three-year-old to the father. I presented several. That was a long time ago. My son just turned fifteen, this week.

0

A damned good question that I have no real answer for, only guesses and it was probably some amount of all of them. My exwife was not one to solve problems and she was impetuous. After her boyfriend mudered her I was the temp executor of her estate (her parents asked me to). I went through some of her stuff for the police and my own questions, but never for a reason.

0

Because she left before the wedding happened. 😛

4

Because my partner found it impossible to resist attractive younger people!

Jnei Level 8 Mar 17, 2018
0

We were two very ambitious individuals who were going through med school and nurse practitioner school. The stress of trying to study, earn and the day to day was too much for us. We are still good friends and occasional lovers but she has her priorities and I have my own and they just don't coincide at the moment.

1

The wrong place, with the wrong person at the wrong time.

3

It was time...

2

My wife was insane and we jumped into things too quickly.

0

I am totally aware that she will give you a different story. For example, I worry about money and sent her home to Africa 3 times out of the 12 years. She will claim we never had any money worries. It simply is not true.
I found that many people you know and work with will cut your throat behind your back. Since I am older, they did that all the time. Doubt was planted maybe coz it's just a game to some people.
The biggest thing I found is that people can grow apart and go in differnt directions over time. Some tell me it was the age difference. I disagree. Both her and I have memories of electricity coming to us for the first time. She lived with her parents then. I lived with my grandparents. The stories were much the same.
Putting my marriage failure squarely upon myself, I bit off more than I could chew. She was going to be the "forever love" that would be with me the rest of my life. Somewhere in my idiot brain I thought I could retire and she would be the breadwinner. Sorry. Things just do not work like that. Today I have a less than $200 mortgage. Hers is much more than that.
Who would have ever thought a simple plan like that could fail? Love is not only blind, it just has no sense at all.

0

My first wife was georgeous, had a beautiful voice and played the classical guitar. She was also bi-polar and it got worse as time went on. After her father died the problem turned into adultry. Need I say more.

My second, long term relationship (she did not want to marry and had a good reason) was to a women who was alcoholic. It was manageable at first and then she went into detox and the next 5 years were wonderful. She relapsed and then things fell apart.

By this time I was starting to get the picture. Take my time and pay attention. It's the old fool me once adage.

6

The short story: My ex was a binge drinker.

The long story: A few times a year he would drink to the point of puking (on various surfaces) and blacking out. Once passed out right in front of the toilet. That's when my pity for his drinking problem stopped. I asked him to get help and he never did. 3 years before our divorce, he went out drinking and never came home. I got a call at 730 am that he was in county jail he had a BAL of 0.20 and he said he barely felt that drunk. I paid his $1000 bail. He also had a few suicide gestures, with his handgun. The last time I had to talk him down from the edge, it gave me PTSD, because I told him that the next time he did that I would have to call 911, so I grabbed the phone and told him I was going to call. He told me he could pull the trigger before they ever got there.

Our kids were sleeping upstairs.

I froze for about a minute, and then told him if that's what he felt he needed to do, that he needed to take it somewhere else because our children were sleeping upstairs.

He snapped out of it, but left the house for about an hour.

The next day I turned him into his church (at that time he was working the sound board of his church for about a year) and told them I couldn't deal with this problem anymore and could they help. They did.

After that, I got into therapy and al-anon and adult children of alcoholics. Two years later, we divorced. It was probably the best thing for both of us, because then he, too went into ACA. No, not AA because he didn't want to give up the drinking. But at least he's getting some kind of help.

I found existing with an alcoholic a living nightmare. Glad we're both out!

Went to AA, Alanon and ACOA-Adult Children of Alcoholics was the key.

@Freespirit64 It really is. I am so glad I recovered my strength and hope. It felt so hopeless for so long.

@sassygirl3869 As you know, it's based on a trauma model and gets to the root of our issues and it was the only place I could actually be heard without judgment, cry about what happened in front of others and still feel safe and accepted. No one was ever going to run back to my family with the family secrets I spilled. The best thing ever and I will be eternally grateful for having those people have my back and be there for me when I was pretty much lost.

I'm glad you found it working for you too.

I finally broke the pattern 9 years ago. An Inner Child Class is what finally opened my eyes.

@sassygirl3869 I am so glad for you. I do feel that inner child work is the thing that heals us best.

1

Mostly because I changed and he didn't. He looked 20 years into the future and was totally happy with it. I looked 20 years into the future and was completely unhappy with it. However, we'd probably still be married if he hadn't asked me the wrong question at the wrong time. New Years Eve he asked if I was happy. I said no, I think I want a divorce. Six months later, I was a single mother.

0

I was in a very strict cult that only allowed people in certain church groups to court and marry. With a severly restricted pool of eligible singles, I finally found a girl I had a good connection with. Unfortunately, I didn't think of her as my type, or necessarily a very attractive woman. But I felt like I didn't have any better options.

After 5 years together, things were unravelling, and I finally left the cult. We separated shortly after that, she wanted to remain a part of that group. So, multiple reasons, married for the wrong motivation, didn't have much in common in terms of interests/hobbies, and the religion/cult messed up both of us.

0

I can tell you why I've never tied the knot

AdieG Level 4 Mar 17, 2018
1

My ex got pregnant with another guy.

Damn, that crossed a few lines!

0

It was never real in the first place and I thought with my cock and not my brain but never again.many things including never feeling part of her family and I don't believe in marriage but stupidly thought it could save the unsaveable.

1

#1: Schizophrenia and borderline personality disorder combined with unwillingness to receive standard-of-care treatment. Decision cemented by waking up one night with her hovering over me, trance-like, with a butcher knife. That sort of thing is clarifying.

#2: She died.

Not all Personality Disorders are awful. Sincerely, Obsessive Compulsive Personality Disorder with some Aversive traits.

My mother was Borderline Personality Disorder, those make me run screaming!

2

I think ultimately I was weak, unassertive, and blinded by feelings, and she was selfish, a bad friend, and downright immoral.

Yeah, don't get married, and don't put up with any bull ever. People have their faults, but take it from a guy that is desperately trying to keep his life together for someone else's mistakes: marriage makes things obligatory. Once you get married, there isn't that same threat that you aren't going to put up with their bull and leave, and obligation will have you overlooking some things you shouldn't. And if they love you, marriage isn't going to be what solidifies that. It literally changes nothing except some paperwork and maybe social status, but it shouldn't do anything for your actual relationship, and if it does, it's probably a red flag.

And as someone experiencing this as a male, let me tell you that if things go south, in terms of relationships, you're probably going be way worse off than your female counterpart even if you did everything you were supposed to do and they messed it up because many women won't mess with a married guy, but most guys do not care. Just my advice.

1

While I was in Australia visiting my sister he moved in his 86 year old mother for ME to take care of when I got home. Lots of other reasons but that was the last straw.

Shhhhiiiitttttty!

1

My marriage failed because I was reared fundamentalist Southern Baptist and couldn't accept my sexual orientation, gay, until my 40s. Annnd she is truly 'cuckoo for cocoa puffs'. She's #MessianicJewish now after Methodism, Baptist, Presbyterian etc. 3 of our 4 children will have nothing to do with her. They've been seriously hurt by her religion(s).

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:38682
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.