Agnostic.com

59 26

One of the posts I read indicated that being an atheist or an agnostic is a choice we make. Is this the way most feel? I am of the opinion that it is not so much a choice as an inevitability to those who truly question with an open mind.

RMNODDING 4 Oct 21
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

59 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I really don’t think we can control what we believe or disbelieve. If an assertion seems reasonable to us we will lean toward belief. Belief will arise spontaneously.

But why is it thought important to believe or disbelieve? To emphasize belief, to expect belief in some assertion—that kills belief right there. Belief has to come on its own. That’s one of my main objections to Christianity: “Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ and thou shalt be saved”—that statement immediately guarantees disbelief by naturally skeptical people.

7

I feel it would be more correct to say that theists make a choice to believe a grand delusion in spite of the fact that there is absolutely no evidence to support it. Atheists on the other hand simply suspend judgement until some valid evidence is put forth. Myself, I guess it is more accurate to say I choose not to believe in these fairy tales based on said lack of evidence but I didn’t simply wake up one day and say “I think I’m going to be atheist from now on”

Cinco Level 5 Oct 22, 2019
6

Yes, thinking scientifically is the choice. And that choice is what leads to atheism.

5

For me it wasn't a choice to stop believing in my family's religion. I think it was the need to know more how things worked and what made sense in my life.

4

According to Process Philosophy, atheists and agnostics do not have a choice in what they believe (or don't) because this is where their current level of understanding has taken them. It's basically the same principle for theists as well. We do have a choice whether to remain open to new higher levels of understanding and continue the growth process or to be satisfied where we are because we feel that we have reached our potential or discovered all there is to know. As a wise old sage once said "Keep your feet on the ground and keep reaching for the stars." Pretty good advice.

yes, exactly, which in fact is why I have to concede that I am an agnostic.

4

Yes! It's not a choice! It just happens to be logical. If anything religion is the choice of those who cannot accept reality.

4

"Mom, I decided I'm an atheist," I told my mother in the kitchen. "I don't want to go to church anymore."

"That's fine, honey," she replied. "In nursing school, I became an atheist when I realized a woman cannot turn into salt." She laughed. Raised Catholic, Mom attended Catholic schools through college. Intelligent, athletic and witty, she was a great role model.

My parents didn't care. Dad never attended church. Mom dropped us kids off for Sunday school at First United Methodist Church, where Dad attended as a child. Mom went home to bed.

Puzzling that they subtly dropped you off on Sunday, even though she, at least, was an atheist.

@LucyLoohoo

Maybe my parents thought we would learn morals at Sunday school. With four highly intelligent, spirited kids, they had their hands full.

My parents sent us to church, I'm sure, because it was the only alone time together they had.

@LiterateHiker And...did that work? It never worked for me.

@LucyLoohoo

Yes. I never went to church again. My parents respected my decision.

@LiterateHiker My mother forced me to go to Sunday School/''worship'' at a church just down the street from us. I had a great memory as a child and they used me as a kind of ''kid expert'' on the bibble...I remember learning the entire second chapter of Luke and parroting it out at some big service or another. Oh...they loved me! Then, one day, in a meeting of some kind, I put my bible on the floor because there was no room on my lap. (I was about 10, I think). The preacher spoke in a VERY LOUD VOICE about a ''girl'' who thought so little of her sacred book that she put it on the floor! He rambled on for a long time. I was humiliated.

I never went back.

But...I'd already sat through Wednesday night ''prayer meetings,'' when people would stand up and ask for prayers because their husband was drinking or their wife was too depressed to ''do her duty'', etc. Even at 9-10, I felt this was horribly embarrassing and was miserable listening to it.

They'd conclude with an ''altar call,'' when everyone had to go up to the preacher and be ''saved.''

I refused to do that. And today...I'm proud of little me....

4

I don't feel it as a choice, it's just the final step that starts by reading, questioning, thinking...

4

No. Not any more than it is a choice to believe or not believe in santa clause. You can pretend he's still there and act like he is, but you'll always know the truth that he's not.

3

I look at it asd atheism is the natural state. Believing in the supernatural, and/or magical thinking is a choice up to a point... some people just don't know any better. Once a person is indoctrinated into religion though, then rational thought has to fight against human instinct for a sense of community, and most choose to conintue because religion gives them a sense of community, which they don't want to lose.

Humans are "herd" animals. As we evolved as animals, being a part of a group made us safer, as in safety in numbers. Our animal instincts are still active and we tend to seek out communities in which we belong, because it makes us feel safe and gives us a sense of well being. That sense of community, in my opinion, is the only positive thing religion provieds, but the instinct to be a part of a group is so strong that many people abandon virtually all common sense to gain that feeling of safety and well being associated with being a part of a group.

3

Belief is not a choice. Choosing to believe is a lie.

That's right!

I've puzzled over your words. "Choosing to believe is a lie?" Bring an "agnostic neo-deist," I believe SOMETHING; not sure what, exactly. Does that count?

@Storm1752
Not being sure is an honest state of mind.
Believing, not believing and not being sure are all honest responses. How can someone CHOOSE to believe? Saying I choose to believe is like saying my mind believes X but for the sake of convenience I "choose" to believe Y.

3

It was a realization, not a choice. At 13, I realized the Bible is just a book of stories written by men.

Michigan had a hard winter that year. Restless and bored, my little brother, 10, and I read the World Book Encyclopedias together.

Reading about rational philosophers Spinoza and Descartes inspired me. In the 1600s when heretics were burned at the stake, they were bravely anti-theist (anti-god), anti-clergy and anti-church.

Their writings inspired the Age of Enlightenment, a European intellectual movement of the 17th and 18th centuries that emphasized the use of science and reason to advance understanding of the universe and to improve the human condition. The goals of the Enlightenment were knowledge, freedom, and happiness.

3

It IS a logical kind of 'choice' in that a person can elect to read, study and realize that the Goat-Herders Guide to the Galaxy is 99.99999% bullshit and then opt for living in and with Logic, Reasoning and Reality OR, conversely, opt out and become one of the Faithfools and spend your existence in fear, superstition and fantasy,etc.

3

I don’t think it’s much of a choice whether to believe what we find believable, and we don’t have much choice in what we are circumstantially exposed to, but we do have a choice whether to dig for deeper exposure or to accept what circumstance has given us.

skado Level 9 Oct 21, 2019
3

IMHO is it is a choice... A choice born from reason and wisdom. I thought the whole Bible time was silly when I was around 8 years old!

The older I became (and the more I read the Bible) I became convinced that it was all nonsense.

3

Well for me it certainly wasn't just a choice. I was convinced there is no loving god of creation. And I lived as a christian for 40 years.

3

When children are brainwashed with religion, they no longer have the capacity to question or to choose.

Some do and, in my experiences with those that have, are, more often than not, the persons for their choice of becoming Atheists even though, at times, it results in them being ostracized to some extent.

@Triphid The brainwashing is not always adequate.

Went to Baptist Sunday School every Sunday and got perfect attendance awards for a number of consecutive years. My aunt (who lived with us) read us bedtime stories from the Bible (King James version) every night. Married a Baptist who was raised by two Baptists who were raised by two Baptists and who herself raised two Baptists (my daughters).All of my siblings are religious, if not all Baptist. I wonder what level of brainwashing would have worked in my case?

@RMNODDING Seems it can also be overdone.

3

It was my choice to be honest about my level of belief/non-belief first with myself and then with others. I could've chosen to stay in denial and pretended to believe, going through the motions. When that became more effort than it was worth. I chose a different path, namely letting go of the illusions.

3

I don't believe it is a choice, or at least it wasn't for me. From earliest childhood, I never believed the God story, and as hard as I tried to believe in a God, it wouldn't happen, due to logic. God seemed as silly to me as Santa Claus or the Easter Bunny. As Clarence Darrow once said: "I do not believe in God because I do not believe in Mother Goose." That said, I am still somewhat of an agnostic, because I can never be sure 100% about what is out there.

3

I chose to be sceptical of everything I read in the bible...or maybe I was just less susceptible to believing it than any of my friends. I was brought up by my parents to think for myself and to make up my own mind, so perhaps because I wasn’t told what to believe, but was allowed to decide for myself, I lacked the indoctrination of those friends whose parents were believers.

3

Welcome to the asylum. Enjoy your stay.

Personally, I am certain that we are all born atheists. Meaning we simply do not believe in gods, religion, anything supernatural, or spiritual.
Everything else requires indoctrination.

Humans are the only species to sexually mutilate children and to exhibit a culture of rape and ideology of murder en masse....religions were invented by shamans to rape women and brainwash boys into killing neighboring tribes....all life is Atheistic until hallucinations set in and victims retell their nightmares as guiding principles

@GreenAtheist While all that is true, none of it has anything to do with the original post.

3

You can look at it either way. As a one time believer I was tortured mentally for not following what I believed and it was driving me nuts. Logic and reasoning set in after I heard Jerry DeWitt talk of his experiences on You Tube. Jerry was one of the first graduates of the Clergy Project. It was easy for me to identify with him in this and I felt as if my eyes were opened for the first time. My guilt was gone, fear was all gone, and it all made so much sense. There are no gods.

Bare in mind that along with belief in gods everything supernatural went right out the window as well. If you believe in anything supernatural it is because you do not understand it. Logic and demonstrable evidence is the only way to go.

I went to church every Sunday when I was a kid. I got perfect attendance awards. My aunt used to read us the bible (King James version) as bedtime stories, but I have no memory of ever believing. For me there was no choice made.But it just seems to me that a person doesn't usually choose what to believe. It either makes sense to them or it doesn't.

3

I think of it more a choice I did not make

2

All beliefs are a choice. The ultimate questions don't have verifiable answers. Some can accept that and other cannot.

2

For me it was knowledge learned. You aren't born an Atheist... Just like you aren't born religious. It is what SOME do in life. I don't go by what others tell me... I go by what I see with my own eyes... What I experience personally.

They have a name for people stupid enough to believe everything they are told.

They are called Trump supporters!

2

I don’t think it’s a choice. I would describe very little of the inner workings of my mind as a choice

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:416760
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.