Agnostic.com

77 13

Are there songs that have distinct religious messages or even religious overtones that you like anyway? I think many songs i heard in church were beautiful. Even songs on the radio such as Spirit in the Sky.

Tinocca 7 Nov 3
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

77 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

2

I enjoy some music even if it is God-focused, though other God-focused music I do not enjoy. I think a God theme bothers me more with some other art forms (novels or movies for example) but with music, I'm not very big on words compared to the music, and even if I pay attention to the words, I sometimes am able to "suspend disbelief" as to what is inspiring the artist and (more) enjoy simply how inspired they are. A good example is the Amazing Grace double album of live gospel by Aretha Franklin, from the early 1970s.

Also, you didn't ask this, but the flip side of this coin is I do not automatically like some atheist-themed music. I don't know if this is because I don't pay much attention to lyrics, or for some other reason. Also, I was not raised Christian, so there are not as many issues there for me as to just taking it in and enjoying the music. To me it's sometimes just kind of exotic, and with attractive sing-along qualities, and wonderful harmonies, and great mastery of certain instruments.

Yes, if I really sit around and analyze it, I am conflicted about enjoying God-oriented music, but I've spent too many years more or less enjoying certain music fully to let this stop me.

A side-point, but much of what I know of Christianity is from listening to (and enjoying) the music for Jesus Christ Superstar, and watching the movie a few times (though I will say I don't enjoy the movie or show as much, more just the album, and there are times or ways in which I don't like it... it's just hard for me to resist the genius of Andrew Lloyd Weber.

kmaz Level 7 Nov 3, 2019

Agreed. Music can lift me up, regardless of the lyrics. And sometimes, the most uplifting notes are written with religious thoughts sung to them. I still do enjoy them. It is different with books or movies. They can all too easily slip into preachy, judgmental tones and that is unappealing.

I think Jesus Christ Superstar is more of a parody of the biblical story. A satire.

Hi @Storm1752

I can't agree, and I've never seen anyone else put forth that idea. A parody or satire to me would be more something like Life of Brian. I'm not entirely sure what Webber, Rice and any others who might have been involved had on their minds, and it is certainly possible that they had a more secular concept in their minds than some viewers might want to believe (I really don't know) but (even if true) this is quite a bit different to me than saying they were trying to make fun of the Christ story, .... for humor at the expense of believers, which is what "parody" or "satire" would imply to me.

I think the reason I"m writing out my disagreement is that I really did dislike the story when I saw it live. A parody, if well done, or done in a certain way, might really have been enjoyable to me, but the actual story, if it takes itself seriously and if the audience is asked to take it seriously, was such a downer to me, and part of the reason for that was not just the obvious death aspect, but the mixed reaction I have about those parts where I'm apparently supposed to draw some inspiration.

6

My Sweet Lord

twill Level 7 Nov 3, 2019

Good one!

5

I adore "Hallelujah", which if you actually read the words (Youtube!) Is actually one of the least religious songs out there yet sounds musically like a hymn.

5

In Your Eyes, by Peter Gabriel. It's supposed to have a double religious/romantic meaning. I love it.

I like the song. I was not aware of any religious meaning behind it. I’ll have to listen again.

Some things I've read about it say it has a double meaning. Probably just conjecture.

4

Sweet! Thanks.

4

Also Cat Stevens.

3

My favourite would have to be Hallelujah by Leonard Cohen sung by Jeff Beck: beautiful

Such a shame him and his dad died young πŸ™ Leonard had a better run πŸ™‚

This is a pretty version. Thanks.

I miss LC

@Davesnothere never seen that before, love the line,
β€˜I had my demons, but they were middle class and lame’
😊

3

BOBBY BARE "Drop Kick Me Jesus"

Wow. Just wow.

@Tinocca Beautiful ain't it? πŸ™‚

@Sticks48 um, sure, you could call it that. Lol

@Tinocca I had the pleasure of hanging out with him, Bobby not Jesus, after a show one night. He was a very funny man, and he was a very nice man.

@Sticks48 well that certainly gives it more meaning to you. This is the first time I’ve ever heard this song or this singer.

@Tinocca He had a number of hits on the country charts during country's real peak in the 70s and 80s. If I was going to pick a real religious song it would be Amazing Grace only because we used to do a kick ass version of it in the 70s. We were nonbelievers , but it was a fun song to play and the country/country rock audiences we played to really liked it. We just kind of pulled it out of our ass one night after touring with Willie and hearing it every night, and we liked the way it came out. It kind of built all through the song until be the end of the song it was big.

3

I'm a total atheist but I like Ave Maria. Once when I was in the Cologne Cathedral in Germany i listened to Ave Maria while taking it all in. The history and environment was intense. Don't know what it means but the experience was intense.

Which one? I have sung a few different Ave Maria’s...my own favourite is the Schubert one.

@Marionville Schubert. The history and cathedrals of Europe are an overwhelming experience for someone coming from a recent culture.

@rogueflyer Yes...I can understand that...Cologne Cathedral is a massive gothic structure! I suppose we Europeans are more used to seeing medieval structures such as cathedrals than those of you from the New World, but they still inspire awe in me too.

3

Nice choice.

3

Last century, I was driving at night and was passing a big restaurant called "Dante's Inferno" At the exact same time they were playing "Light My Fire" on the radio. Not exactly religious but whenever I hear it I make this connection.

3

Despite the fact that it tells a story that I absolutely do not believe, "O Holy Night" is probably my favorite Christmas carol. It's just a very beautiful piece of music. The instrumental version by Mannheim Steamroller moves me to tears.

I sing this with my choir almost every year.

3

Stevie brings up god all the time in his lyrics and I don’t mind at all.

I haven’t heard this song before. I like it. Nice groove to it. Thanks for this one!

@Tinocca Second track on Songs in the Key of Life. I like all of his stuff of course. A national treasure.

@indirect76 Stevie is a genius.

3

I used to listen to a group call The Second Chapter of Acts when I was younger. I still occasionally listen to them because I love their harmonies. At the moment I'm obsessed with a group called The Hu. It's more spirituality then religion (they're a Mongolian Heavy Metal band), but their music is awesome.

Enjoy! I love good harmonies, as well.

Same way with me as far as The Second Chapter and also Barry McGuire during his Christian rock days.

2

Nice voice. I like it.

2

One of my faves is Led Zeppelin's In My Time of Dying:

I owned that vinal once . . .πŸ™‚

@Davesnothere my brother had every Zeppelin record. He listened to them all the time.

@Tinocca I had them all too, only most now digitized.

2

Belinda Carlisle - Heaven Is A Place On Earth

Sure, that’s a religious reference. In the slightest sense. I did set the bar pretty low for songs to fit the question, so I guess this works. Thanks!

2

No, I don't listen to songs with religious content, there are some that sound good though, I like "Oh lord won't you buy me a mercedes benz" by Janis Joplin.

I just heard that song a few days ago. Nice.

2

One more song that I love is " My sweet lord " by George Harrison. Actually anything by him is awesome

Yes, great song and artist. Thank you. One of my favorites as well.

2

I can listen to music and enjoy it without having to believe in the message.Norman Greenbaum is just one of many who wrote some great stuff that I can enjoy without having to buy into the words

2

One of Us by Joan Osborne

twill Level 7 Nov 3, 2019

Yes! Good one.

2

The Coronation Mass by Mozart is very beautiful and uplifting.

2

"We shall overcome."

2

I love quite a few hymns and Christmas Carols just because. Handels Messiah is a masterpiece a with a lot of church music of the baroque period as the church had the money to pay the top guys.

Power of Love by Frankie is pretty remarkable. Music is not restricted to the culture it was born into. It transcends all that nonsense.

Absolutely. I didn’t even start with all the Christmas songs I love. That is too big a list. O Holy Night is exquisite to me. I agree about Handel’s Messiah as well. So moving! Thanks for the input.

Around here several churches have "Messiah" sings where they hand out music & everybody partakes, usually followed by cookies & coffee. Tons of fun!

@AnneWimsey My sister sang in those for several years.

2

Least religious "religious-sounding" song on the planet, actually about the bItter side of human love , betrayal, loss.

@AnneWimsey Lots of Christians mistake this song as religious...obviously haven’t really listened to it properly.

2

I think there are melodies that connect wIth us on a pre-historical basis, that have little to with us In a modern basis - simply put, they just sound goodπŸ™‚

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:421977
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.