Agnostic.com

13 2

A big contingent of my wife's bible thumping family is coming to our house for the weekend. I know they'll want to say grace before every meal, but I usually just dive into food and don't give then a chance to initiate.
Should I give them the opportunity or rule over my domain with an atheist fist?

ThorR 5 June 1
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

13 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I forgot my manners one holiday dinner at my aunt's and dove right in. We skipped grace that year. Apparently no one wanted to interrupt me.

0

Unexpressed gratitude is like having a present and not opening it. If someone wants to express gratitude, why not let them. If they begin to proselytize, then it's my house and I can stop it.

0

yes because the world will end if you say a prayer. it's not us vs. them.

0

If they accept your role and you feel like being gracious, then let them pray.
If someone wants to make it a battle, let them know they are on foreign turf. IMO

0

picking battles is crucial.

0

I'd be a gracious host and let them get their nonsensical 10 second prayer out of the way. I wouldn't bow my head or say amen, but I'll let them have their moment. Now if they start speaking in tongues, then it's a whole new ballgame. Also, I might have to borrow some money off these chumps someday, so....

1

That all depends if you want war or peace. You can make it fun though, when they say grace and thank the lord you can add to thank the cow that gave the milk, the farmer that grew the potatoes, the illegal immigrants who did the hard slog and picked the vegetables because the Americans do not want to do those hard jobs for pittance. How about that angle of it all?

0

Why give in? It's your house so don't let them have the high ground in this. Also, imagine over 2000 years ago with no refrigeration and people praying, thanking god for the food, and asking that it be used "for the nourishment of their bodies." I know exactly what that means under the circumstances.
Todays believer goes right into how god controls everything and without him you would have no food. Wrong! Just totally wrong on the "grace" idea. It should be self evident.

0

I don't have a problem with religious people bowing their head and saying a personal but silent prayer while I go about eating my dinner. The god is in their head according to their book so he'll hear it just as well as if they were hollering it out from the mountain top while the food gets cold.

4

Tell them that in your house you do not say grace prior to eating, but it is fine if they choose to privately thank their god for whatever they like - after all, their god knows all of their thoughts, so they have no need to say anything out loud.

Excellent!

0

Your house, your rules

1

If it's a big contingent it might be easier to serve the food buffet style. Then arrange to be at the start of the line and just start eating as soon as you have your food. Situation solved without any confrontation. But if you want to fight all weekend, then just don't give them a chance to start grace before you chow down.

1

You should be a gracious host.
Grace at dinner is ok. You don't have to say amen or anything.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:96531
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.