Agnostic.com

38 3

Do you believe that we have souls? If so, can you answer why?

AccursedHalo 6 Dec 27

Post a comment Reply Add Photo

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

38 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Are you talking about the missing 21 grams from a dead body? Never was quite sure if that measurement was accurate. It could have unexplained physics like when a room is dark the air in it is more dense. Or what you see is not light but the refraction of an object the light bounces off. You never see light only refraction. If you never see light how can it have a speed? Just like time if it is not measured does it actually exist? Energy has a weight just to weigh it is absurd. So 21 grams could just be the half life of the last drop of energy has changed into some other form. Just a perception in realy.

9

I believe there so you don't get dirt and stuff in the flesh under your feet and it makes standing easier.

9

No, I don't believe in souls, I believe we are all in our physical brain. I have cared for people with encephalopathy and also transient global amnesia. Looking at what parts of the person remain when most is gone is a real eye opener. Personality changes, memory loss, and how things change back when they recover. Makes you realises that everything that makes them who they are is in their brain and body, nothing extra somal.

Interesting observations!

9

It's an interesting thought, but the evidence suggests that all mental functions take place in the brain, including the chemical reactions which induce emotions. I'm afraid I'm not a chemistry or biology student, so I can't be much more specific than that. So, there doesn't seem to be anything beyond the mind.

6

No. That is part of the religious mythology and is used as an inducement to attract followers, promising eternal life.

4

Why should we? To me this is another anthropocentric word that has been in use so long that even the non-religious consider it plausible.

like I love you with all my heart which is a blood pump.

@Duke I had a girl love me with her hole butt once. It was amazing.

@LeighShelton How about I Love you with all my mind. To me that makes it real and based on something more than emotional feelings.

well that's the truth but you hardly know me

4

I have longed for the consciousness to live on. You know, energy being neither created or destroyed sort of thing... BUT, a recent first experience with surgical anesthesia has me considering that to be more of a pipe dream than anything.

Zster Level 8 Dec 27, 2017
4

Defining "soul" is the first task. I'll abdicate right away.

3

No. If I had a soul, I'd have traded it for something more useful by now.

3

I think I'd need a clear definition of "soul" to properly answer this. Some people use it metaphorically, others mean the sentient quality, and still others refer to a metaphysical, immaterial, immortal substance. I have no problem with metaphor, but see no reason to refer to sentience as "the soul." And in terms of metaphysics, I see it as fine for thought experiments in philosophical discussion, but I don't accept the claim that it's somehow who we are now and eternally. I see no indication it's true or that anyone should take the claim seriously.

3

I don't know if we have "souls". I really hope that when my body quits, my mind/personality quits, too. It would give me great peace if I could be assured that when I'm gone, I am gone. Who knows. What matters is that we try to live decent lives. Just be honest, ethical and decent.

SKH78 Level 8 Dec 27, 2017
3

One of the odd things about our language is that it enables us to talk about things that do not exist, unicorns or the bandersnatch and it extends to conversation about things that we can neither prove or disprove.
The notion of a soul would imply something that was implanted.....

Implanted? Like a pacemaker?

I think the problem arises when the words we use have a religious connotation. To me it is a way of promoting religion which, for me, should not be promoted. Besides it is helps us think about what we say.

3

No. never have

3

Soul music maybe

2

It depends on how soul or spirit is defined.
If it is like how when someone dies in a movie, and you see their spirit leave their body, then no, I don't believe in that.

But in anime or cartoons how the spirit leaves the body when they get hurt is really funny tho! Lmaooo

@AccursedHalo yea i love how anime portrays it
Lol watching some now

2

I cannot say for certain but it doesn't look likely. Having said that, my atoms become new things, and this is spiritual for me, so if a soul is a spirit, then perhaps the new organization of atoms is like me in some insignificant way.

If that's true, you're just millions of other people and things...

If you mean that our bodies undergo continual change throughout our lifetime, I would agree. The river may look the same but we never step into the same river twice according to Heraclitus

2

No. I mean, my understanding the definition is that it’s a consciousness hat persists after death. Our consciousness, who we are, can be obliterated by Alzheimer’s...that to me indicates our consciousness resides in the brain and upon brain death, ceases to exist. The energy animating us carries no consciousness of its own...

2

I'm glad to see reasonable answers here. I have heard so many people ask "you don't believe in heaven? Where do you think we go when we die?" To me, that is someone who hasn't given it much thought at all. How can you go anywhere when you are dead?

2

To me it seems that most Christians view the soul as something separate from the body, and leaves the body when a person dies. In that sense, I don't believe there is any soul, given what we know about how brain and body chemistry affects thinking, emotion and behavior. When our bodies die, we die completely.

2

We don't; we are energy.

2

connection between neurons that contain memories .. is ur soul .. the way they emerged from the beginning till the end .. that makes you who you are .. well some say it will be gone when u die .. some say by law of thermodynamic nothing will be gone it will just change to another form of energy

2

As much as we desire it to be so. Its like before you were born. You didn't exist, knew nothing and felt nothing. There will never be another like you.

How do you know that you didn't exist before you were born? The only reason we're capable of perceiving this existence is because of our brain. Energy is only transformed never destroyed.

1

I HAVE soul but I'll NEVER be able to reach those hallowed levels of the late, great James Brown. HEH

Seriously, I entertain several definitions of A "soul". I have experiences more in a creative, "spiritual" sense which makes any "everlasting" possibilities of little consequence.

1

Yes, I do. Yet my concept of what a soul is, what does it do and where does it reside is a little bit different than what most religions teach.

1

It may be our residual star dust energy develops a collective unconsciousness?

1

I don't really know. I've reached a mindset where scientific and spiritual understanding run parallel at times. We can break everything down into human measurements and patterns and scientific theories and laws but it doesn't take the wonder out of it for me. So as far souls go... I don't think, if they exist, that most people have them. In which case it could be a matter of higher consciousness and potency (specifically in regards to something like reincarnation). But take away a certain chemical or part of the brain, and you have a completely different person, so... I think when I die I just won't exist anymore. Just whatever unconscious energy I carry that will return to everything.

Cwen Level 4 Dec 27, 2017

It just sucks to think all of this is for nothing.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:11004
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.