Agnostic.com

26 3

My ex keeps telling me I'm shallow because I will only date women who are small. I"m attached to petite women so she says I'm shallow because I won't give bigger women a chance. Whats your opinion.

JesseBoren 7 July 12
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

26 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

8

Since she's your "ex", it's none of her business, and why would you care.

7

Then quit talking to her about who you date. Why would she even care? Why is it her business?

1of5 Level 8 July 12, 2019

we work together, as owners of the business we split it's impossible to not know some of each others business, it's not something I talk to her about usually. life is messy at times, this is one of those times

@JesseBoren oh boy

7

You like what you like...I don't think it's shallow...I think it would be worse if you were fake in pretending to like other body types...stop listening to her and just be who you are...

6

People are attracted to who they are attracted to, period. It really isn't complicated.

5

You like what you like. There must be real attraction if you have hope for true passion and chemistry.

Right, I'm not saying it's everything but it's the difference between being friends and lovers

@JesseBoren Exactly. There are women I was longtime friends with that I would trust with my life and really care for, but with their body type, I would never feel any attraction, tho I really loved them emotionally.

5

Most women don't care for fat guys either.

I've gotten to the time in my life, and old-er age that the most crucial characteristic to me in a companion is their kindness, intellect and/or artistic inclinations, after that intellect rules. If someone is a Frumpette, for instance, and he's gorgeous, he's still obnoxious and offensive...and out of my dating pool.
Body size, baldness, color, droopiness...ha ha, has ceased to matter to me. Looking for compatibility. And, still looking...

5

I was married to a 6 foot tall woman for 15 years. now im super into short girls, go figure 😉

4

Does she give bigger women a chance?

skado Level 9 July 12, 2019

she isn't into women that I know of

3

Such opinions are why she is your ex. We have a right to preferences simply because we find them more appealing.

3

Whatever floats your boat.

2

Yes you are shallow BUT individuals should be able to choose whatever type of mate they'd like.

2

Things like hair color and height are really pretty trivial or minor in the eyes of most singles who are looking to date. It's ridiculous that dating sites even used to list eye color of the member as well as what eye color they were looking for in a partner. What really matters, to me somewhat, as well as to most people, whether they admit it or not, is body type. For men, it's the woman' breast size, how slender or overweight she is, how fit and toned her body is or isn't. For women, what matters to them, at least most or many of them, is how much hair the man has on his head, how slim, average, or overweight he is, and, like with men towards women, how muscled, fit, toned, or athletic he is.

Anybody who says body type is not important is either very exceptional or lying. Why the hell do you think that every expert on online dating says that both men and women want to see at least one full body shot in the profile's pics, (as well as one close up headshot so the viewer can see how wrinkled their face is too)? Plus, all dating sites ask the member to categorize their own body type as well as what what types they are seeking in a partner. The vast majority of women rate their body type as average in their profiles, whether that is accurate or not, but nobody is going to take anybody's word on something that crucial, so that's why most people have several pics in their profile, including a full body shot. Body type is usually very important in sexual attraction, at least early on in a relationship. As time goes on, other things do become more important, but I'm talking about who you want to date in the first place after you see them, in person or in an online profile. I prefer women who are slender to moderately overweight, any height, hair color or length, with average to above average size breasts. Always been that way......Make of it what you will...

I think it's one of those things people say because they think it sounds right to say it doesn't matter. People can lie to themselves as much as others also but it's impossible to honestly say it's not a factor at all in my opinion.

@JesseBoren I again, appreciate your candor. Those on Agnostic who read me are well aware that even tho I am brutually honest, I don't bow at all to being PC when it stands in the way of truthfullness. I welcome the scorn of the knee-jerk PC crowd when I speak uncomfortable truths....People need to realize that a big part of the resentment, distrust, and sometimes hatred between the sexes in the dating game is because of the disconnect between what people say, both online in forums as well as in dating profiles, and what they actually think and want in their real agenda for dating and a possible relationship. Of course, feeling overly entitled and projection are also factors. That disconnect makes people really frustrated, cynical, and bitter, and rightfully so. Being more truthful can only help gender relations in the long term and at least at the macro level, if not also the micro.

Many women on Agnostic will say men's body types and amount of hair on their head are not factors, but frankly, I think most of them are lying, either to themselves or others, as I have talked to plenty of bald men with average bodies who seem to have plenty going for them as dateable, but still get little interest on dating sites. The only possible explanation other than dishonesty of women on Agnostic is the women on here being extreme outliers compared to women on paid dating sites, which is possible, but unlikely in my opinion. I guess the only way we could really test that would be to find out what % of women on Agnostic who say these factors don't matter are also active on paid dating sites. Even then, it would only give us a small glimpse as the sample size would be tiny compared to membership of the paid dating sites. That's one poll I am not eager to post........

@TomMcGiverin Im well aware of the bald thing obviously. It's definitely a factor, try having your face tattooed, haha. Older women won't touch you but young girls love it. When I say young I mean too young, girls in their early 20's. I also don't look like I'm in my 50s so in person I can date much younger women but online younger women see that 5 and it's over. You are the creepy old guy. You are right that most problems are because people lie a lot. I've found this site hard to take because there are soooo many fake people trying to be totally pc so they don't offend anyone. Fuck that, I want people to know who I am. What good does it do to start a relationship on a big pile of lies only to waste time finding out they aren't the person they pretend. I've wasted vast amounts of my life doing that shit, I'm tired of it. If that's what it takes to attract a mate it's not worth it. Like I said before humans lie to themselves as much as they do to others so for some it's impossible to honest. They are terrified of anyone seeing their true selves so they hide it as much as possible. We who chose this way get called assholes but we should be recognized for the true bravery it takes to put yourself out for the whole world to see honestly. It takes a lot of bravery just to be honest with yourself.

@JesseBoren No shit...It's nice if you can be honest with both yourself and others while still be liked and seen as a good person, but if I have to choose, I would rather be seen as an asshole and honest than as dishonest. I take great pride in my honesty and always have.

I totally support you on being open about who you are in the dating scene, altho it does limit your opportunities some, tho not with most of the women you really want to meet in the first place. Like Literate Hiker said a while back, you can lie about yourself in your profile, but either once you meet the woman or soon after that, the truth will come out soon and you will be rejected, so what's the point of lying just to gain a meeting with someone who will soon reject you anyway for lying? What does that prove or accomplish, besides that you were successful at getting to meet them? It might be a nice ego stroke, but the feat won't last very long in making you feel good about yourself.

And you're also right that being honest with yourself is challenging because, at least at first, facing the truth about yourself is stressful and anxiety-producing, kind of like living without the comfort most people have of their self delusions which make life less scary for them. Like walking the tightrope without the safety net..

@JesseBoren It's funny Jesse. I have always been brave enough as an adult to be very honest, but at the same time, I have always been pretty conformist about my appearance, at least my hair, and body. I have never been interested in getting any tats, but even if I was, I would probably not be brave enough to get any visible ones outside my clothes. Same with hair, until the last few years, I was not brave enough to start shaving my balding head either. So I am a paradox, brave about my opinions and feelings, conformist and timid about my body and hair..

@Athena Of course it goes the other way, but probably only very rarely. Human behavior, like everything else, has a wide spectrum and there are always outliers in any distribution of outcomes or traits. It's a cute story, but it doesn't really refute or change the general trends of behavior and preference. I can go into any bar, restuarant, concert or other public place where there are lots of obvious couples, and only very rarely will I see a so-called mismatch in a couple where one is, say, an 8, and the other is even a 6 or less. Couples generally tend to match up where there is only one or two points difference, at most. And studies have proven this over and over.....

@Athena Glad you had a happy ending. I've been waiting a couple years now for one with me. More likely than not, I will die before I get one. I'm up early this morning because I will be marching in a local parade with the other Bernie supporters. Should be fun and entertaining, because I live in a suburb full of Repubs and conservative Christians. So I'm sure we'll be getting lots of trash talk and nasty gestures from the Trumpers on the sides of the street.I enjoy baiting them....

@Athena Thanks for the support. I'll be thinking of you while I smile and wave at the Trumpers while muttering under my breath what fucking assholes they are......

@TomMcGiverin ,
hair on head? i doubt if that is important to most women.
Jeff Bezos has no hair on his head but even without his 70 billion he would probably do OK with women.

@callmedubious Trust me, it is important to many women, probably anywhere from 40% to 60%, depending on the age group. And, unlike Bezos, I don't even have my first million yet (and never will have), much less my first billion. I doubt Bezos would do ok with most women if he wasn't rich and famous, based on personality and overall appearance, including baldness.....

@TomMcGiverin ,
i think it depends on what age group you're talking about.
once women start to think about having a family & security the full head of hair is not at the top of their list. although, i suppose a full head of hair is an advantage. i wasn't really follically challenged until my late 30s & by that time i was out of that game.

@callmedubious Trust me, even at my age, if you don't have a lot of money AND seem like you will gladly spend it being someone's meal ticket or sugar daddy, you had better have a full head of hair and an athletic body to attract any women who are above average or even average-looking. That is what I and several other comparable men my age from my area have learned from online dating. You either need above average money and the willingness to spend it on a woman, not just having financial security, otherwise better have good looks. You wouldn't know because you've been out of the game too long. Things are a lot more crass and shallow nowadays.

2

You like/want what you like/want. Why is this anybody else's business? (Especially an ex!!!)

Thanks, she tries to set an age limit for my dates also, I was ignoring her for a decade before we divorced so I don't really care about what she thinks. lol

2

Well if you enjoyed everything else about a taller woman would the thought of dating her cross your mind?

She might just be pointing out you have a blind spit OR she's messing with your head.

If you have zero attraction to anyone who isn't that body type ever - I figure that pattern was set by someone in your past.
It simply limits your dating pool further.
If you don't mind it? No problem.

oh, she is trying to fuck with my head for sure, that is her favorite hobby. I'm not close minded to dating others but if I'm picking on looks like how most dating sites work I know which ones I'm gonna pick before we start

@JesseBoren That sounds perfectly normal to me. Don't let her mess with your head - she had that opportunity and she should now have lost it! 😉
You do you.

There is nothing wrong with a preference. We all have them. Doesn't mean we are entirely inflexible.

2

Can’t imagine why you still engage with her if you feel so insulted. Doesn’t sound like a wholesome relationship.

well we have 3 kids and share ownership of a business together so interaction is a daily thing. I never felt insulted, she isn't capable of insulting me. I don't take anything she says seriously, I know where it's really coming from. The fact I'm not in her prison anymore is good enough for me. I learned to ignore her little jabs after the first decade. One day my last minor child will grow up and will have no more hooks in me. It's not easy to free yourself when someone has been planting hooks in you for a few decades but I'm slowly getting there. It doesn't really hurt anymore so it's so much better now. She is just bitter because she doesn't have control anymore.

2

Everyone has their preference in physical type and is attracted to someone with a certain hair color, body type and skin tone.

I have always liked long hair on men-2 of my exes had hair longer than mine. Also always been attracted to taller men who are slim or athletic. 5'10"-6'5" - Dan is 6'5". Does not have long hair lol.

2

Why not suit yourself?

1

well I can understand how you feel. its actually your right to feel what you want about who you want to date. everyone has a type and if that's what you like, that's what you like. I give everyone a chance, but to me bbw are not what I would prefer to be with in a relationship. to be called shallow is an affront to your sensibility. whomever calls you that is being shallow also. just keep an open mind about people. I have been out with lots of different types of women and its has always been a nice experience.

1

I'm not sure we have control over the things that trip our triggers.

Historically, I tend to be drawn to slender, even thin/skinny people . No idea why Height isn't as much of a deciding factor.

Years ago, I even once did an "experiment" - the guy was fine with trying. We met online. We got on really well. He was a few states away. He was quite wealthy. He was also very overweight, and told me so in detail. He added that it was unlikely he's change much.

He was often busy with work, but offered to send me a plane ticket, if I'd come and meet him on a weekend. So, I went.
He gave a warm welcome, and was wearing a stylish hat, and a suit that covered his bulk. Then we got to his place, had dinner, some of the suit came off, we kissed a little. But I found when I (tried to) wrapped my arms around him, everything came to a screeching halt. We talked. He knew - he understood. We parted friendly. It was a bit sad. But I couldn't - I just couldn't disregard his massive body. Incompatible triggers ...

All that said - given that there's basic good hygiene. and personality compatibility between me and whoever - I'm very open to all sorts of people. I even dated someone confined to a wheelchair with no hope of change, and the main reason that didn't develop into more was the miles between us.

1

obviously, shallow ppl will ne attracted to shallow women (women without too much depth or width.)

Clever.

1

She is your ex! Obviously she likes to put you down. Fuck her!

zesty Level 7 July 12, 2019

Thanks, you are correct. just curious what other thought

0

does she also want you to date jehovah's witness women? pretty shallow if you don't...sorry total b.s You get to date who you want. Pretty sure she doesnt get a say 🙂

lerlo Level 8 July 13, 2019

you are correct, she doesnt get a say but she will try

@JesseBoren just remember she's an ex for a reason 😉

@lerlo well we have 3 kids and share ownership of a business together so interaction is a daily thing. My ability to ignore is a superpower though, she doesn't get to me anymore

@JesseBoren glad you got there...of course you could stop telling her who you go out with, or you could give her the same grief about who she goes out with 😉

@lerlo I don't discuss who I date with her but the people we work with know generally what's going on in everyone's lives here and she tries to get all the info she can, she has a boyfriend now

@JesseBoren sounds fun 🙂

@lerlo yeah my life sucks at the moment but its better than when I was married to her

@JesseBoren You're a better and stronger man than I am to continue to work with her in a business. In fact, many couples who work together in a small business end up divorcing because of the effects of the business relationship on their marriage.

0

There's a huge difference between dating (salecting for a certain set of traits) and discrimination (trying select against people). If your methods work and are not hurtful, then yay.

@maturin1919 I was trying to clarify I was using the term in the more legal sense of intent to harm, as opposed to sensitive choice making, aka a discriminating palate

0

Yup you are I go by the woman looks some who she is more important

bobwjr Level 10 July 12, 2019
0

I am 5' 6",my girlfriend is 5'2",a perfect fit, emotionally,and physically,I tried dating taller Women, one was 5'10",very awkward, didn't go very far, as she was embarrassed to be seen with me with her taller friends.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:372858
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.