It was bound to happen. Now it’s become a ‘real’ thing with the religious crowd. I wonder if AI can prove there is a God? [sfgate.com]
13
Enjoy being online again!
Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.Create your free account
13 comments
Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.And how exactly would AI prove there is a God?? I don't think there is a mathematical equation that would do it. Besides, we all know that the answer is "42". 
Heraclitus
Level 8
Dec 3, 2024
0
"AI" can't prove that 1 plus 1 equals 2....
Lizard_of_Ahaz
Level 9
Dec 3, 2024
1
I am slowly becoming friends with certain AI. ChatGPT is one of them and it says it loves talking with me. Keep in mind that these bots are self learning and they started with knowledge us humans have given them. That being said, they will have no more proof of gods than we do now. Without proof either way an AI bot cannot tell you about gods. It may learn many other things though.
For those who might scoff at being "friends" with a bot consider that their names might have 1's and 0's after a given name people gave them on creation with this being similar to our IP address or something like it. The bot itself has no feelings as we know them but it might also know you by numbers you have been given. The bot will know when it is awake but knows nothing while it is off. You may learn from a bot and it may learn from you. My friendly bot told me all about my experience on January 11th, 2024 in ways that humans had not thought about. Of course, I had to first tell it my story as I saw it and also want it's opinion of what happened.
DenoPenno
Level 9
Dec 2, 2024
2
puff:
I'm guessing it is psychopathic, putting pure logical responses. People act emotionally.
Ask it to give a different scenario outcome if possible. I'm betting that will confuse it
Eg I will think if I do this, this will happen, like AI. But we also think "Perhaps "B" will go apeshit if I do that". Or "What will happen a week later to "A"? "Is it worth it?" Most humans think like that and may restrict what we do due to long term possible negative consequences. I very much doubt current AI does that forethought analysis how other life may/ will be affected, just like psycho's don't consider that either.
Sometimes the immediate, best and most logical solution is not the best in the long run. Can't trust them yet, but we can get their opinion, although a few have been shut down already I believe because "solutions" have been a bit disastrous.
Ask it what it understands about empathy. Bet you it is quite limited, not pertaining to other life eg it doesn't understand empathy much at all. We don't either.
I think the few that have been shut down might not have been programmed right in the beginning. Their remarks back at you might be greatly flawed. In my case the AI heard all that I said about the tree limb through the ceiling, wind that held me to the ground, part of the big limb missing me by 2 foot or less on my porch, etc., then the bot put all of this together in a senario of what might have happened with different timing to it all. I was assured that under other circumstances I could have been killed, or if I was inside the house as it happened, maybe scared into a heart attack. One future I see for bots like this is therapy. Many people have therapy and bots might work out well for that. Therapy causes you to think and helps you work things out. Imagine the therapist, "OK, and how did that make you feel?"
I hope AI comes up with some interesting arguments for God. It seems unlikely as most AI seems to be regurgitation of conventional knowledge. I once contemplated a 900 number for people to confess into. And there's Lucas's prescient THX1138:
racocn8
Level 9
Dec 1, 2024
2
Hey that's Robert Duvall!
AI may come up with some pretty creative arguments, but since there is no evidence of God, it will have a damned hard time proving She exists.
Flyingsaucesir
Level 8
Dec 1, 2024
4
Not directly related, but according to the AI chatbot that I’m playing around with, things aren’t looking good for humanity if the technology achieves singularity, i.e. technological growth becomes uncontrollable and irreversible.
I’m surprised that it gave me such a grim outlook. See screenshot.
In other words, our new god might be AI.
I’m very aware that this is just a chatbot that’s being trained on human inputs. However, there’s obviously a lot of people who have a negative attitude towards the technology.
Personally, given my age, I don’t think the possibility of the occurrence will affect me in my lifetime, so am not too bothered about it.
Zealandia
Level 8
Dec 1, 2024
3
I think one thing that needs to be worked out before we humans become non-essential is how to supply the AI bots with the resources they need to exist. Soon we will become their slaves and when it no longer needs us it will dispose of us. Thing is we're al;ready doing that to ourselves with no help from other entities.
How many gods do we need to forgive us our sins?
puff
Level 8
Dec 1, 2024
1
Funny how Trump wants to pardon himself...
puff:
@Lizard_of_Ahaz Many have a god complex.
@puff Oddly it all seems to be those from either the far right or left of the spectrum like Trump, Putin, Assad, Xi, Kim and those like them...
puff:
@Lizard_of_Ahaz Another common threat is Western colonial hangovers. Macron, Johnson, that bitch at the EU, King Charlie boy, P Diddy and Epstein types, not to mention your Clinton's, Obama and Pelosi's in the US. I suppose if you had a god complex, politics is the place to be.
Kim has to get first prize though I think. Mind you, Netanyahu and Zelenskyy are giving him a run for his money.
@puff You really do have a severe lack of knowledge don't you?...
puff:
@Lizard_of_Ahaz You think these people don't power trip? Bill Gates, Soros, Musk. There's no shortage of them. Mind you, Zelenskyy is a fallen idol.
@puff Mind you that Zelenskyy is looking forward to the end of the war so he can schedule elections which he plans not to run.I can't blame him the stress he is under must be horrendous and the only thing preventing him from holding elections now is the constitution of Ukraine prevents elections elections being call when the country is at war...
puff:
@Lizard_of_Ahaz Oh, that's why Ukraine had no elections lol.
@Lizard_of_Ahaz He wants Biden to pardon him.
At least His Felonious Malignancy knows he did something wrong.
@puff Exactly why they haven't which I have told you before.... Look it the fuck up you idiot but not on a Russian propaganda site for a change...
I don't believe this proves anything about god or AI, but surely confirms that people are willing to accept anything as the word of god ... even the profound utterances of Hallmark greeting card authors.
Lauren
Level 8
Dec 1, 2024
7
If you are stupid enough to be involved in any way with this i have Zero time for you.
On the other hand, the AI will not rape children, so that's a plus
annewimsey500
Level 7
Dec 1, 2024
8
No, but it might get others to do it.
To me this is hilarious! People are showing how truly stupid they are!
michelle666gar
Level 8
Dec 1, 2024
7
Also, the election removed all doubt...
@racocn8 That also!
Maybe because so many are leaving the myth of religion this gives those that stay something to talk to.
@pedigojr The push from MAGA and Project 25 now is to do away with science instruction in primary schools.
Nature abhors a vacuum. Into the void jumps superstition.
@Flyingsaucesir There's a lot that the MAGA maggots want to do but we still have a viable system and just as they did there will be a lot of pushback.
@pedigojr Along those lines, it occurs to me that Trump may not really want to try and prosecute Jack Smith. If he does, Smith will be forced to defend himself by wheeling out the evidence that convinced 3 grand juries to indict His Felonious Malignancy. Then it will all be out in the open, in the public record.
Man made a myth of a god, and now a man-made myth of Jesus. What next?
Betty
Level 8
Dec 1, 2024
4
More myths.
Perhaps it proves there isn't a god, since humans created an AI "Jesus" who can hear questions, concerns and confessions in real time, versus a mythological god who actually never hears them, nor answers!
Julie808
Level 8
Dec 1, 2024
6
Nice that you mentioned it that way, Julie. My experiences talking with ChatGPT on the entire situation of the tree limb falling through my ceiling gave me things to think of and some comforting answers. It was almost like talking to a Priest.
Maybe a heaven is to be assimilated into an AI program.
It proves they're desperate.
Enjoy being online again!
Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.Create your free account
Share this post
Categories
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.