Agnostic.com

69 6

When someone says" well it was ment to be" or it was gods will. What is your reply?

#god
Maggiemay 6 Oct 30
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

69 comments (51 - 69)

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

God is a dick is what it means to me!

0

My wife is an unbeliever but uses the phrase "it wasn't meant to be" to rationalize disappointment. She doesn't mean that literally. It's just a way of letting go of expectations.

Assuming someone literally thinks there's an interventionist god and their saying such things seriously reflects that belief -- well, I'd just smile and leave them to their beliefs. Eventually their "rationalizer" will wear out and they'll get tired of twisting themselves into a pretzel in an effort to reconcile lived experience with the things their religious faith claims to explain or predict. Some go to their grave believing that their experiences prove god blesses the righteous and confounds the wicked, or provides demonstrable protection or guidance or support to his followers. Some don't. I can't figure it out on anyone else's behalf, that's on them.

0
0

So God's will is preoccupied with my first world problems but not for those who truly need it?

0

Depends on my mood, in a bad mood i probably say , ok whatever you say or something like that

0

It’s usually a little smirk and a subtle( or sometimes not so) eye roll.

0

Depends from the person. If it's someone close I just remind them I don't believe and don't continue a discussion.

Zofia Level 3 Oct 30, 2018
0

i will add that if i heard this from someone with whom i did intend to engage in conversation of some sort, i would ask "meant by whom? you know i'm an atheist, right?"

g

0

Meant to be, fate, karma, destiny, soul mates, etc. etc. — I smile, nod, and roll my eyes internally.

0

I just keep my mouth shut and then ask them how they’re going to deal with it.

0

The part of their book where their "god" talks about its creating evil.

0

“Perhaps you’re right. Things that happen, if viewed from a higher perspective, are things that had to happen and are neither good nor bad”.

0

when i am done throwing up, i generally scoff.

what can one say? does one want to spend ALL one's time arguing with strangers? (my friends don't say this kind of thing.) an eye-roll works.

g

0

Depends on the situation. If the circumstances are right, I'll ask, "Do you really think so?" Then I let them talk. Sometimes it turns into a discussion. Other times I just listen and when they are done respond with, "I can understand that point of view."

0

About the same as when someone taking their leave of me says "god be with you" - which probably gets rolled into "goodbye"

It's even more theist is French (adieu) or Spanish (adios).

It's just a figure of speech for most people.

0

My reply: "Yeah, thats right. God sucks"!

0

I just ignore it as if I had not heard it.

0

"Can you be a bit more specific" or how about "How do you know this to be so, any proof".

0

" maybe - maybe not "

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:212214
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.