Agnostic.com

14 34

Today’s Bible Study
I’m sure that verse in the Bible where Jesus says, “My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?” was the moment when Jesus finally became an atheist.

Willow_Wisp 8 Aug 4
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

14 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

3

Are you referring to the teller at our seven-eleven?

(Sorry , inappropriate, but couldn’t resist)

The teller at the AM/PM is an Egyptian and everyone knows him as John, but his real name is Hanna which in the west is a female name but in Egypt the most common male name, like John.
We meet at Indian restraints once a month and try a lamb dish we haven't tried in the past.
I'm performing a study on him, as I do everyone I associate with.
He's Christian, Orthodox Christian, so nothing makes sense in his faith. My Ex was also Orthodox Christian and the services were a circus, albeit a healthier circus than the Pentecostal services just more like an Opera presentation. There's like a stage area where priest wearing medieval robes and apparently the design was a collaboration of Michael Angelo, Lady Gaga, and Elton John. they chanted everything in Armenian which no one in attendance understood. They had chains holding big incense pots they were swinging around as if ready for a fight.
It's Cirque du Soleil circa 800ad.
Never let yourself get to hungry, to tired, or to alone.

@Willow_Wisp real people are awesome. World needs more of them. BTW - middle eastern food is wonderful.

@Willow_Wisp also, there isn’t a 7/11 within 50 miles of here. Maybe been in one a couple of times. One of those was in Japan

3

My belief

2

Did it mean he was asking why this was taking so long? If so, why did people remark that he died so quickly? The religious will claim that he "had the sin of the whole world" upon his shoulders. Oh, poor Jebus. Why was he praying out loud in the first place?

3

Since the Father & the Son are the same person, he was obviously speaking to himself, and therefore must have known the answer.

2

Yesterday we had Torah Study. Tomorrow we have Koran Study. But today we have Bible Study. (With all due apologies to Henry Reed: [poetrybyheart.org.uk] .)

3

Talk about self doubt...

4

Interesting that he said "my god" and not "my father", Was he doubting his parentage ?

6

It is my heartfelt spiritual belief that he's not the messiah, he's a very naughty boy.

3

It's a little late. Luckily, we here don't have to die to see the obvious.

4

Don’t forget the fact that there are 3 different versions of last words in Bible. The other two say it is finished and Into my hand I commend my spirit once again proving there is something for everyone in the bible

Into thy hand I commend my spirit
is from the 31st psalm

Bart Erhman discusses the Christmas story from the Gospels. He points out that very few things match up in the stories from the events occurring when Jesus was born - there was about a 10 year gap and no overlap between events identifying when Jesus was born. Mary either had a 10 year birthing process or one of the accounts is wrong. Who showed up at Jesus birth is also different between the accounts. Only one version has the wise men and only another has the Shepard. Only by merging the stories - thus corrupting both - do we get both Shepards and wise men at Jesus birth. The same would be true of Jesus last words on the cross.

Elaine Panels (I believe) wrote about the evolution of how Jesus was deli Ted in the Gospels over time. Mark is the earliest account and has Jesus expressing great suffering and pain on the cross. Matthew and Luke depict his experience as a somewhat less excruciating, and John goes even farther. A number of concepts show an evolution throughout early Christian writing. One of particular interest is how Judas is portrayed - especially into the uncannonized books and lost Gospels. Judas goes from being the evil, Satan possessed villain to being Jesus favorite apostle in the Gospel of Judas who is the only one who truly understands Jesus and his mission. Judas was called to turn Jesus into the authorities as his special mission since none of the other apostles were faithful enough to fulfill this task.

@LenHazell53 Luke 23:46 says

Jesus called out with a loud voice, “Father, into your hands I commit my spirit.” When he had said this, he breathed his last.

@abyers1970 Your using the NIV translation I was using the KJV, both are legitimate translations from Aramaic and Greek for the same phrase.

4

It is the first Line from the 22nd psalm and was a coded sign for some one to give him the poison in the sponge stick (which incidentally is actually a Roman butt cleaning device because toilet paper had not been invented)

8

He’s also apparently, talking to himself. 😬

Mvtt Level 7 Aug 4, 2021
7

Bwaaaaaaaaahaaaaaa...er..Bwaaaaaaaahaaaaahaaaaaa

7

I would have said Bi-polar but that's just me.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:613830
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.