Agnostic.com

74 19

What do you say to people who say, "I'll pray for you", when you tell them you're an atheist? I like to tell them, "and I'll sacrifice a chicken to Shiva for you! " Sounds so much nicer than, "don't bother"...

Coffeeman 7 Oct 13
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

74 comments (26 - 50)

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

3

I reply, "That's unsurprisingly passive-aggressive of you, but whatever gets you through your night..."

Deb57 Level 8 Oct 15, 2019
3

I would say nothing smile and end the conversation.

3

Hitchen's response was, "I will think for you."

But that won't work either.

@heymoe2001 A clear example of why it is a waste of life-time to in any way attempt to change the stupid. Stop trying, and live.

@Jacar , I don't try. I think you missed the point.

@heymoe2001 Depends upon the situation. "I'll think for you" will work sometimes. Laughter at other times. And, usually, just don't respond.

@Jacar , thinking for them will be as effective as their praying for you. Neither actually works.
Do you get it now?

@heymoe2001 I agree. But the question is a about how to respond, not the effectiveness of the response.

@Jacar , I wasn't responding to the question. I was responding to you.
I regret having done that. You are thick

3

I just say 'thank you'...

3

I tell them, if you're gonna pray for me, whatever. I can't stop you. But can I make a request. God's suppose to know what it would take for me to believe in him, correct? Then put a time limit on it. If he doesn't do his magic by the time you finish your prayer, what does that say about your god? He's either so weak he can't do anything, or he don't give a fuck about me going to heaven. I mean, Thomas got to put his fingers into Jesus's wounds in order to believe, and he was an apostle. Either of those, or god is like the tooth fairy or Easter bunny, and just a made up figure. If that correct, what and/or who are you praying to? You could be praying to the devil without knowing it, and where does your prayers go? I'm guessing nowhere to in the room you're saying them in, and it. Prove me wrong... If you hold god to an ultimatum, and time limit on his magic gifts, you'll quickly find out why I think like this do. The bank holds you to a time limit, why can't you do the same to the creator of the universe?

3

I tell them that I view the "I'll pray for you.", as being insincere because it costs them nothing. Then I tell them that if they gave me twenty dollars instead, I would know that they really were being sincere. Or, I will just point out the when people say that they will pray for someone, they do not mean it literally...just using it as an insult.

3

~wink~ and walk away is all I ever need in that scenario 😉

3

I say, great, and I will think for you.

3

The best I have heard, from the TV show that I have never watched, that I now use every time.... 'and I will think for you'

That is a good one!

3

And I will read a book about science for you!

Hehehe!

3

Thank you and I'll write a letter to Santa Claus for you.

3

They all say it but I bet most of them do not do it. There is an old Merle Haggard song with the line "momma used to pray that my crops would fail." That's right, folks. The old-time Christian would pray for their god to not let anything you do prosper you in any way if they thought you were not right with that god. What the hell kind of people is that? I don't need them.

3

If I have told them I am an atheist then their saying they'll pray for me is rude. I ask them not to pray for me. I tell them I would prefer that they did not. It is of course their business whether they pray or not and their prayers can neither hurt nor help me, but their proclaiming it that wayou is offensive and I do let them know it.

g

It's almost always someone who knows I'm a nonbeliever who says, "I'll pray for you." It's condescending. And I guarantee they never actually do it. It's a platitude, and a way for them to let me know that they're so much more righteous than I.

@resserts indeed. it's often in response to one's revealing one is an atheist, not just that they know, but their response, which is awfully ridiculous!

g

2

Keep it real! Appreciate the sentiment & not the ignorance. Unless you're on a mission from God! 😉

I'm on a mission! I'm a militant atheist!

@Coffeeman What do you mean by that?

2

Responding to imbeciles is futile. So i say, "Thank you." And move on.

2

I usually tell them, "fuck you", then go about my business.

Hehehe! Aggressive!

@Coffeeman Actually, I'm holding back.

2

I say 'thank you' and leave it at that.

2

"Just a prayer? ...you ran out of Thoughts? ...and What is the Purpose of that Prayer?"

2

Oh honey, no thank you. With a swift walk away.

2

Maybe, "Enjoy your self-indulgent nonsense."

Stenz Level 6 Oct 14, 2019
2

"'I'll read a book for you", or "I'll thank science for you".

2

I usually say something along the lines of "if it makes you feel better, knock yourself out." But I think I like what @Athena put down.

2

If you could make it a special prayer request. Specifically, if You would pray that Jesus would make everyone on Earth a brick home built by true masons no one would be homeless tomorrow. Considering the universe was build in a week ... what's a few billion homes over night?

Word Level 8 Oct 14, 2019

And should add: free from mortgage, free from rent, free from taxation free from governmental terrorism and free from religious oppression.

2

Seems like every new person asks this question...

No need to be an ass about. A simple, Thank you always works. Regardless of your belief, they are trying to be nice to you. I'll take all the prayers I can get!

2

meh, just say "thanks". We all create our own universe and they're just doing what they must for the crappy one they've constructed for themselves. The absolute best thing you can do is show them you're just fine without their god.

I know it feels good to be hateful and rude to them over it, but that just gives them more power over you than they deserve.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:413809
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.