Agnostic.com

64 7

Back due to popular demand, but please stick to subject of dating photos. Thank you 😉
One for the ladies really: I’m on a dating site and there are so many photos of men looking sad, with shades on, with a beer in front of their faces. It’s kind of hilarious and makes my job as a person looking for someone lovely to spend their life with a lot easier... but here’s the question; what the hell are those guys thinking? I don’t care how handsome you are; if you can’t crack a smile I’m not going to want to date you! Does anyone go for these guys?

  • 5 votes
  • 48 votes
  • 10 votes
girlwithsmiles 8 Nov 1
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

64 comments (26 - 50)

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

3

I need them to at least have one friendly pic . Toxic masculinity is a part of it I think . Trying to look tough

8

No. Anyone with shades or a mask it covering their face is out. If they are trying to hide the face in a profile pic, what else are they hiding?

GwenC Level 7 Nov 1, 2019

With sunglasses probably wrinkles or eye-bags!

@Merseyman1 In mine, I was wearing shade s because I was outside in the sun. I've worn contacts and/or glasses since I was 3, so it just never phased me before. This is only the 2nd online site I've ever built a profile for, so I guess this post is providing me with tips for better photos? 😯😯

1

Maybe another thing to add on to the poll would be men that look proud or powerful. Like the stereo typical picture of a policeman or someone in uniform.

GregM Level 5 Nov 1, 2019

Policeman? I'm liable to think bachelorette party..

5

No. Men looking sad in a dating profile (words and photos) seem to be seeking someone outside their self to make them happy. I would only be interested in someone already happy with their self and life choices, so together we would be doubly happy.

If someone looks to be wanting to drain my happiness for their own needs, well, been there done that. Not interested.

Exactly how I feel, especially after my last partner looking for co dependence. I work full time I don’t have time for caring for a grown man too!

5

My thinking on that is...it is hard to know the real person in a picture! As for ‘smiling’..,that would be way down the list of admirable traits for a partner. A loving heart would trump a smile any day! But, that needs to be determined in person! Usually people are attracted to one another and they can’t easily put their finger on it! They will even miss the flaws at first, lol...keep looking there is bound to be someone who clicks with you!

2

That’s just what you’re looking for.
There’s someone for everyone.
I don’t smile well so I don’t do it.

2

There's plenty that would keep me from considering a man; I skip those who golf, fish, hunt, watch sports obsessively, drink commercial beer from cans, eat red meat and/or junk food, men who've never traveled, men who don't read, etc. In my old age I'm pickier than I've ever been because I now know what I'm not willing to tolerate, or to give up my freedom for.

You've elimated everyone I've ever dated 😂

I should be perfect for you then, IF I was willing to give up MY freedom.

@Storm1752 Exactly.

2

Why are so many selfies taken in cars?

May be a good temp studio!

IKR?! Even videos are done in cars. What is up with that?
I don't think I've ever gotten into my car, checked the rearview and thought, "Ooh! I'm lookin' fine! Gotta take me a pic!"

I tend to wonder if they’re not really single if they post a car selfie. At this stage I don’t care if I get it wrong, I’d rather err on the side of caution. Plus if you were serious surely you’d make the time to take a nice picture somewhere else?

3

I don't get the shades, I mean why hide your face? Beer, seems immature but I will be 53 next month so maybe that's my age showing.

Yes, I feel the same 😉

4

It only worked when we were young, which was the last time a lot of these guys were single. They tend to fall back on what they know. 🙂

1

After reading these comments, I'm apparently screwed. In the only one where I'm NOT smiling, I'm with my cat, and my primary profile pic has sunglasses!!! I am not photogenic and seriously dislike most pics of myself. And, I DO smile alot, so maybe I'm just nuts.

I’m not sure if it’s the same for women, I hate photos too. For my dating selfie I imagined meeting someone that I really liked.

5

Also cigarette in the cover photo eww

I'm surprised that isn't a profile question, actually...

@LisaFultonave some sites have it in their criteria but answering is optional. I've seen lots of guys say they're nonsmokers, but they have a cigar hanging out of their faces in a pic.

1

Looks like there is some research to suggest not smiling isn't too bad for men. Also sad looking is a subjective judgment.
[dailymail.co.uk]

Well they can keep them! And so can you.

@girlwithsmiles I can't stop smiling 😅

6

My ex had surrendered into such manic depression (and refused to even discuss treatment) that his face at rest was eventually starting to look like Jeff Dunham's puppet Walter, so yes, a smile or at least a pleasant demeanor is a must for me in a photo. Three pics in a profile, and all of them frowning, throws up warning flags.

My first wife was/is also Bi-polar and also refused any help. She said all the doctors wanted was to get into her pants (we were part of a military community in Europe). 5 years into the marriage she had her first affair and had 2 more. Once her clearance got taken away because of one of her episodes. She went to a regular medical doctor and he said she was OK so she got her clearance back (crazy). At onetime I thought why not a doctor getting into her pants seems like others (they were all high ranking officers) were. Mental illness is harder to deal with than physical.

@JackPedigo I'd readily agree. Mental illness is, at least for my temperment, more difficult. Particularly if personality characteristics vary dramatically, or impede healthy communication.

@LisaFultonave Absolutely, and communication is the key to any healthy relationship.

1

Not only do they often have a bear in front of them but also what they wear. Singlets are a put off big time.

Oh yes, and shirtless. That puts me off, especially if it’s a selfie taken laying on a bed!

I didn't understand a word of that? Singlets? Bears?

@PondartIncbendog Singlet-British for undershirt, either tee or (usually) wife beater.

@girlwithsmiles no clothes, no contact. Period!

3

It's not so much about a smile, but it seems like some of these guys are trying to look intimidating or too serious. One can have an unsmiling face and still be appealing.

The shaded guys never are attractive for me. And what's with the fish and the cars?

They’re all yours 😉

If men could fish from their cars they would be in heaven.

0

I've been on and off dating sites for a long time now and what I have basically boiled it down to is what women generally want is a guy with money. Rich guys. Of course the dating profile "code" is successful or stable but it seems pretty classist to me. Plus after years of working in wealthy communities where gorgeous women are commonly coupled with rich arrogant slobs I guess I'm cynical

Zzz start a post of your own, what part of, ‘this one is for the ladies’ don’t you get?
It’s one thing to be the first one to comment fishing for complements, but I don’t want your sexist bullshit on this post. Move along.

@girlwithsmiles Oh insulting men, which you did with obvious relish, is one thing. But when men fire back, it's sexist bullshit...
I see.
I will say the women here are of a much higher caliber, overall, than those on your typical "dating site." Probably because this isn't "really" a dating site. Not to me, anyway.

@Storm1752 see comment above to Spinler. I’m not insulting men, I’m discussing what women find attractive or not in a photo on an online dating site. You could read and educate yourself, but you chose to jump to another man’s defence when you see him get challenged.
I’m pretty sure GI can answer for himself... in fact he did so, also above.
Wow this post is hard work! Lols.

2

Well it seems that most women feel the same as me. Some don’t, and have their reasons; which are interesting. The men have a bit to say too 😊
Good luck with the dating all.

@MichaelSpinler Please, write your own post, this is about how women perceive men’s photos. Game playing is a different subject again. Perhaps yourself @GIjeff04 and @storm1752 can start one, you all seem to have your own agenda on this post.

@girlwithsmiles sorry. I thought I was answering the post with what I thought was relevant anecdotal experience. Obviously it was a generalization. I certainly have met amazing people from online but they are few and far between and I'm referring to the pay-for dating sites. Not this site. I saw gals griping about guys and guys can gripe about gals, it seemed reasonable at the time. Sorry to cause any consternation. Hope you have a great weekend

@MichaelSpinler I’m not man bashing and and not sexist. The genders perceive things differently, yes it’s a spectrum and not an absolute. This is the first post I’ve ever made that has been gender specific... and will probably be the last due to the nightmare comments.
@GIjeff04 I’m sorry you got conned into one of those paid sites, some do string you along to get your money and are not a true reflection of dating as the women get paid to post. Unless you’re talking eharmony; that’s legit 😉

@MichaelSpinler assumptions, assumptions and an inability to converse about the topic at hand. Good evening.

@girlwithsmiles this motherfucker honestly went and accused you and this post of man-bashing and being sexist... yeesh sounds like an incel! Yikes! I guess the OP had to specifically state this is about this demographic of men, NOT ALL MEN! NOT ALL MEN! NOT ALL MEN! And yes multiple times in caps locks because the notallmen brigade are kinda slow and do not catch it if you say it once in lowercase letters... trust me I've tried. xD

2

Sad and a beer? That's sad...

The beer is warm 😟

1

Never could figure that shit out , very puzzled by it

4

I've tried POF and it was nothing short of a nightmare.
The "ladies" were for the most part the biggest collection of losers I ever saw: ugly, overweight, ignorant, you name it. OR so conceited you better be a fortuitous combination of Robert Redford and Bill Gates or you don't stand a chance.
The decent ones are so deluged with garbage mail it's impossible to get a response.
If you ever DO make it to the fateful "meeting" they are so jaded and cynical you feel you've stumbled into your own personal Inquisition, or the world's worst job interview.
No thanks. I'll just hope lady luck shines on me again someday, and leave the trendy "dating sites" for my fellows with iron egos and unbreakable hearts.
Incidentally, I've learned to steer clear of this place as a "dating site" as well. It's too valuable to me as a community resource to spoil it. If I do approach a woman, it's for friendship only...much better that way.

@Storm1752 I agree with the bad job interview statement.

You get what you expect in life, generally...just sayin'

Well stated and correct.

I’m overweight, does that mean I don’t deserve to date?

@Marcie1974 No, of course not.
I'm an abnormal person and talk funny. How about me? Fixed income, asocial, reclusive...any takers?
Once you get past the horribly bad first impression, my true magnificence becomes apparent, but by then she's gone, baby, gone!
(Did I mention my hilarious but all-but-impenetrable sense of humor?)

@Storm1752 I was specifically referring to you saying:

“ The "ladies" were for the most part the biggest collection of losers I ever saw: ugly, overweight, ignorant, you name it. ”

Makes it sound like you think overweight women are losers.

@Marcie1974 I was ranting, reacting angrily.
I've been thinking a lot about this today, and my considered opinion we ALL have our "ideal" in mind; unfortunately our ideal is probably also everybody else's in our "subculture," AS WELL AS in the dominant culture.
In the culture at large, why do the rich men always have the most beautiful women? Because women want rich men, and men want beautiful women? It would certainly seem so!
In OUR group, it may be incrementally different. I believe it is.
Our overall opinions on the fundamentally BASIC issues of life take a more central role. It's not as blatant a sell-out with us, as it is on meat-market sites like POF, where the quid pro quo is nakedly obvious.
BUT, things such as physical attractiveness, intelligence, financial stability, etc., etc., are still important.
I'd say that's fair.
I'd have thought our choices are more enlightened, but the basic, nuts-and-bolts realities are the same.
To the original question, maybe that's why a lot of men don't CARE about their physical appearance? Maybe they know it's irrelevant; they've always been successful looking like slobs, why change? Maybe the well-groomed guys are just telegraphing their shortcomings!

0

he whole planet is a potential dating site. there all about money which is obvious. laughing is everything in the end really with honesty and respect. if you can't make an effort right at the start it doesnt look good for the future really.

There all about money? Do you mean they're? And if so, do you mean women?

@Cutiebeauty not women but the sites xx

@LeighShelton haha okay

I do know someone who worked for a paid site for men, it was called something like bored housewife’s and she was paid to string men along. But I know they’re not all like that, my old bosses daughter met her husband online. For me the paid sites were no better/ worse than the free ones though. Pictures included!

@girlwithsmiles your right and even if they are honest you don't know about the individuels on them

7

So many of them presenting their manliness with a big ugly dead fish. Cracks me up.

As long as the man keeps his shirt on for the dang picture, I wouldn't mind seeing a dead fish.

7

I have gotten off dating sites altogether because of this. The pic that still haunts my dreams was an extremely close up selfie of a man whose face was so red he appeared to be actively pooping

5

I'm no longer on any and haven't been for some time. Too many reasons to avoid them to list them all. I just go do what makes me happy. No need for looking. If someone worthwhile comes along...fine! If not, I'll go on vacation, walk, go out to eat, etc, and do things that I truly want to do.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:421112
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.