Agnostic.com

56 4

Does the evidence for reincarnation prove (at least some kind of) 'god' exists?

Storm1752 8 Sep 8
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

56 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

To my knowledge there is no proof of reincarnation. And since it is the religious that make the claim that God or Gods exists then as Carl Sagan put it "extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence".

When I see evidence then I’ll believe it.

10

Since when is there "evidence" for the existence of reincarnation????

9

What scientific evidence exists on reincarnation? None.

9

What evidence is there for reincarnation?

8

What evidence ?

8

I really miss being a flying dragon unicorn 😔

Mvtt Level 7 Sep 8, 2020
7

What evidence? Nonsense.

6

What evidence is there for reincarnation!? 😲

6

Do you have some evidence of reincarnation?

5

No because reincarnation is bullshit along with the rest of religion

5

The "evidence" proves some folks are loony...

4

No evidence.
The stories are compelling and not verifiable.

4

If you have evidence for reincarnation. Go get a hold of the JREF (James Randi Educational Foundation), and claim your Million Dollars.
Let me know how that goes.
lol.

4

I am not aware of any evidence for reincarnation. So, does the lack of any evidence for reincarnation disprove the existenceo of any Gods?

4

As soon as there is concrete evidence for reincarnation then I will think about reevaluating my beliefs. So basically when metaphorical hell freezes over.

4

What evidence for reincarnation?

What is reincarnated?
It is well established that, when part of the brain is injured, a certain aspect of a person's perception or personality is changed/damaged.
There is no ghost in the machine.

4

There is no evidence of that bullshit.

4

All "evidence" for reincarnation is anecdotal; someone claiming memories of a past life telling colorful tales of their time as an Egyptian priest or a Viking marauder but with nothing to verify it.

"All "evidence" for reincarnation is anecdotal" Exactly! And people lie, invent stories, and are more willing to believe romantic nonsense.

And isn't it interesting that they'e never a slave or a peon or a convited criminal about to be hung?

@HumanistJohn Valid point.

4

We have fallible brains. That’s the only evidence.

Mvtt Level 7 Sep 8, 2020
4

I read and watched some from the links provided, and that's just not evidence. People have kidnapped and murderd their own children for attention, so I wouldn't put something like this past anyone. And if you're going to do it at all, why not make it as crazy and convincing as possible?

3

Does the evidence of the recently discovered remains of Adolf Hitler found on the moon prove the existence of god????????

Same answer.

3

OP asks what is the logical linkage between the two ideas and the answer I hereby give is that the two scales of "possibility" are mutually and freely independent of each other. By their nature one might have either, neither, or both (bearing in mind the senses of the job title are infinite). This interrelationship in logic will not be altered by any amount or quality of evidence either / both has /doesn't have.

3

WHAT 'evidence for reincarnation'?

3

There is no proof of reincarnation except for anecdotal evidence. In all scientific communities that I know of, this isn't proof.

By the way, I do believe in reincarnation because of my own anecdotal evidence. It's just not provable.

3

zero evidence, major bullshit

3

If you keep up these kinds of statements and questions you will be an 8 soon.

Sure got the mileage outta this one

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:532330
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.