Agnostic.com

51 14

So good people of the universe, how do you all handle the assumption from Christians that you believe in Jesus? I meet alot of people in my profession that assume I believe in Jesus and I find it a struggle to politely tell them that I don't without the feeling of them condeming my soul to hell.

Capricorn 6 Oct 22
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

51 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

7

Yeah, when I go to a chinese restaurant, sometimes the waiters would start speaking in Mandarin to me, and I have to explain 1) I don't speak Mandarin; and 2) I barely speak Korean.

They politely nod and leave me alone, but I know that they judge me. Silently. In Mandarin.

🙂

Damn, that's awful

Not laughing at the experience, but you worded that hilariously.

5

When I tell them I'm agnostic, I usually get the reaction that reminds me of an old Star Trek episode. An accusing finger slowly points towards me and then I hear the words, "You're not of the body!" This alerts other Christians who slowly encircle me, reminding me of Invasion Of The Body Snatchers. Desperately I make my escape and outrun them, reaching the sanctuary of my home. Bolting the door behind me, I can only hope that the ' No Soliciting ' sign will keep them at bay. Sorry. Did I wander off topic?

I remember the episode and I agree it is just like that.
Thank you, chucklesIII

5

I take the stance that I have assumed they are atheists, as what idiot would be otherwise, and merrily offend away. Very satisfying.

4

Lately I have been mentioning that I don’t believe in magical thinking.

4

Then don't be polite. Here's a sample response :"nah, I think that's superstitious horseshit" Chances are, they'll never make that same assumption again. YMMV ?

4

Interestingly enough, I don't get that. Maybe it's the horns protruding from forehead.

3

Depends on the day. Sometimes I tell them I worship my lord and master Satan. Then I tell them I’m just joking I don’t believe in God or Satan.
I think it must be more relieving for them to be speaking to an Athiest rather than a satan worshipper.
Lol

3

I've run into this in the past. In more recent years, I don't hesitate to set them straight, and I don't even think about how they might condemn me. I hope you can get to this point, too.

3

I find it most difficult among other black folks. It’s as though they wanna take my black card if I’m not a Christian

Omg black people think Jesus is the answer to every damn thing, it's a straight mental disorder

3

I just let it be known. So. Many say, I'll pray for you, I know you don't believe in that sort of thing. And instead of my answer, don't bother. I just say thank you. I have no feelings one way or the other. Not to believe is very refreshing to me. Makes me feel free to do as I want knowing this is it baby. Make it a great life.

3

I ignore it unless pressed, then I tell them that I'm an atheist. It seems to disappoint them that I'm not a screaming monster as an atheist but someone they thought was a good person. The dichotomy is something that they find difficult to deal with.

I think that's the best way to insert the thin end of the wedge.

I like how you worded “someone they thought was a good person.” It is surprising how many religious people correlate being religious with being a good person. Anyone that gets to know me and then finds out I’m an atheist is usually surprised that I am one.

3

Only had one vistor wanting to talk about religion recently ( months ago), told him I was atheist. He said okay and left....in just a little bit he came back asking if I would be willing to talk about my beliefs, and I asked "why"?.. he said he had never met anyone claiming to be atheist, (this is a very small town). So I said sure and we sat on the tailgate of my pick-up and had a talk. His first question was why was I an atheist, and I told him because in don't believe in gods. He said so you think you're right, and millions of others are wrong. I said "yeah". Later he left with a "thank you" , I enjoyed the talk. Think I planted some seeds.

3

I have no problem telling them my beliefs when they impose theirs on me all the time.

3

you will have to put up with their condemnation. tell them as politely as you can, which i am sure you're already doing, and then their attitude is THEIR problem.

g

3

Very situational; depends on how militant they are and how respectfully they conduct themselves.

Militant = Sarcasm "That's adorable!"

Respectful = Compassionate dialog about how I just couldn't talk myself into believing anymore, but I'm glad It's working out for you.

2

I live in the south where religion runs rampant, so that's something I get a lot. It always annoys me when someone assumes that of me or tells me "Good bless you". But I try and ignore it as I think they generally just mean well. And I'm really not very confrontational either, so I can let most things slide. However, if I feel there is a real need to defend myself I have no problem doing so. However, I try to always do so politely and respectfully to throw people off since they think atheists are just savage cave dwelling beasts with no manners.

2

Oh yes! Jesus Gonzales! I believe he makes the best encheladas I've ever had. And a real gentleman as well.

2

It depends how I'm feeling that day, sometimes I just can't be bothered to answer the plethora of questions when religious people find out I'm a nonbeliever.

2

It can be scary. I just say I don't believe and then wait for the fallout. I have several stickers on my car from Freedom from Religion Foundation. One says: when religion rued the world, it was called the dark ages. From a biker guy, I have been told I will burn in hell! Sometimes people come up to me and say: I love your stickers! So, there are hidden supporters too.

About them stickers 😉 I had one that stated "Dog is my co-pilot" (the play on God is my co-pilot stickers). My kids scraped it off as they are believers....I put up another one and they scraped it off as well...So much for freedom of speech!

2

I tell them I quit attending church when my mother quit bribing me to go.

2

I don't think there is any point in disputing the idea that a guy named Jesus lived and gave some pretty good talks. When it comes all the claims of supernatural acts, that's where I demand independently-verifiable evidence. Put up or shut up. What? You don't have any? Well that is revealing...

Actually, Christians can't prove that Christ existed.

@Minotaur80
True dat.

Actually, it is highly UNlikely that Jesus of Nazareth ever existed. For example, we know that Nazareth didn't exist until the late 3rd century.

2

As I’ve said before, my beliefs or non are nobody’s business but mine. I generally keep my mouth shut, just nod or smile at what they are saying. Change the subject.

2

I say it's stupid to assume that everyone is the same religion as you. I don't know how to answer politely, because it is stupid. I guess. I'm direct, and I get more respect when I'm direct. Sometimes I just say, I'm an Atheist, I do not believe in God at all.

2

Thanks ladies & gents for the advice, you all have a good afternoon! ?

2

They don't need to know.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:206272
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.