Agnostic.com

59 19

What would you do/say if a Christian friend told you they're questioning their faith? He didn't ask me questions. He knows I'm a non-believer. He simply said, "Two weeks ago I woke up and all my faith was evaporated." He's sill wants to believe but is starting to doubt it.

In a situation like this, would you go full force into it and tell him you think "this and that" about Christianity and try to de-convert him? Or would you say nothing until he asks questions?

All I said was "Why is your faith becoming evaporated?" He didn't really know how to answer that question and went around in circles. I didn't tell him what I truly think the Bible is all about and why I don't believe. I want him to figure it out himself. If he asks questions, sure...I'll tell him what I feel. But simply just saying what he said doesn't really give me any desire to start telling him what I think.

Would you feel the same as me?

VeronicaAnn 7 May 17
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

59 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

You did so well there. Let him come to you if he needs to.

8

I would start out reassuring my friend that I would remain their friend regardless what they decided. Then I would offer to be a listening ear and let him know if they wanted any resources, I could help with that. Losing one's faith can be a very difficult process since there are all sorts of underlying threats of torture, pain, and rejection. They will receive plenty of pressure to conform; they won't need me to be one more source of pressure. They need the freedom to figure out their own thoughts and feelings.

5

I would have said, "I can understand that. It happened to me many years ago."

5

Your initial response was perfect. I hope he will come to you with a more specific answer and some questions. I think it is best to wait for that to happen for several reasons. The primary reason being, he needs ownership of his decision for it to be permanent.

I think it is almost comical that my atheist friends here almost all encourage you to refrain from leading or pushing non belief while almost all religions encourage or demand proselytizing non believers. Atheists are often accused of attempting to recruit while the truth is actually the opposite.

4

What worked with my son was I gave him a book of Bible stories written for children. I asked him to read the stories and tell me what he believed and what he didn't believe. He did not believe:

  1. The Universe was created in 6 days.
  2. The Star of Bethlehem could lead people to the place where Jesus was born.

Once he realized that some things in the Bible could not be true, it was easy to point out all the things with Noah's Ark, Jonah and the Whale, Moses parting the Red Sea, etc, that could also not be true.

BD66 Level 8 May 17, 2020
4

He seems to be coming around but it is a personal thing and he might take years yet to de-convert. One problem wit believers is that they keep going around in circles. Be supportive but not pushy. In time most people see their god is really imaginary.

4

Everyone's journey is different.

If your friend wants to ask you anything, he will. When/if he does, answer him.
That's really all you can do.

4

Just encourage him to continue investigating his doubts and come to his own conclusions.

4

I think you did well. If your friend asks, then you share your thoughts but I would highlight that it was your position/opinion about things. Even if your friend starts moving away from the faith in religion, he might still have a different position/opinion about things from you.

4

why do people have a need to convince others what to believe?

Why should anyone suffer (what they consider to be) foolishness in silence ?

I sincerely wish NOBODY did that.

@VeronikaAnnJ . . . your question presumes facts not-in-evidence. 😮

4

I'd probably try to stoke his critical thinking on the topic by asking him some questions starting with why he feels his faith is dwindling and based on that proceed forward.. My goal wouldn't be to deconvert him so much as to get him to critically analyze his faith while he's in the frame of mind to do so before blind faith takes over again..

3

I just listen to what they're saying, if they ask me for input then I will tell them what I think.

3

My response would be, "If you would like help sorting out your thoughts and feelings, I would be happy to listen and discuss." And that's where I would leave it until I got a response. He may not be looking for advice.

Deb57 Level 8 May 18, 2020
3

I would simply say, welcome to reality. I don’t think I would dive into a discussion, but I would say you’re welcome to ask me any questions because I’m sure there’s many you need answered.

Yes, that's it. I'm that person, more and more doubting. It's hard to find people to ask questions about this. I'm formerly a clergyperson.

@Doubting The most intoxicating aspect of Christianity is the most difficult to free yourself of, and that's faith. Church's celebrate those willing to offer great faith. However, once you understand why faith is a manipulative concept, religious control begins to disintegrate. Faith is used both as a metric of knowledge and trust interchangeably amongst theists. It's a useless tool for knowledge, anybody can have faith in anything, and trust in the supernatural is unwarranted.

@paul1967 Yes, true, though I struggle with whether the faith in the christian god is actually credible, based on the manuscript evidence, which I know academically. But yes, agreed.

@Doubting Do you accept that a good God could ever endorse this: Exodus 21:7 "When a man sells his daughter as a slave. Or Exodus 21:20-21 "When a man strikes his slave, male or female, with a rod and the slave dies under his hand, he shall be avenged. 21 But if the slave survives a day or two, he is not to be avenged, for the slave is his money. It's this and many other passages that make a good loving God a contradiction.

@paul1967 Whether he is 'good' or not is beside the point in one sense, for the prior question is whether he exists and who defines good. But that said, the slavery envisaged in exodus is about people acting as servants to pay off debts. But still, I find the texts you mention very distasteful as you do.

3

I often refer them to resources that are designed to help those questioning their faith. Or if I can ask them questions that I asked myself. The main thing is to let them know it is normal to question ones faith.

3

I would tell them I've been an atheist all my adult life. I'd let them express their feelings and I'd do it best not to influence them. I don't like people to try to influence me.

3

I would congratulate him on his quest for a better state of mind (the turmoil of questioning is much better than que quiescence of blind faith). I would congratulate him on his mental growth, and I would be honest with him and with myself by admitting and expressing that his questioning could take him either way; rejection or back to full embrace, and of course, perhaps something in between. I am an antitheist, but I would place friendship above beliefs and I would support him on his journey, wherever it may take him. And if he were to ask me, since he knows my stance about religion, then I would go full force and give him the good news about living free and with full ownership of his mind, and I would do it full force not only because I would want him to know, but also because why would I withhold knowledge from him?; a half measure in my response to him would also be dishonest.

3

The word "friend" is one that I do not use lightly -- someone I can say anything to and hear anything from without losing my temper or self-confidence.

If you can't be HONEST with a 'friend', perhaps they never were. 😮 😛

This !🙌

@VeronikaAnnJ When I commented -- "be HONEST with a 'friend' ", -- I 'got' it -- and I meant it. 😮 😛

@VeronikaAnnJ . . . then we disagree. When I say HONEST, I mean say ALL (and exactly) what I think -- I say what I mean, and mean what I say, that doesn't make me a mean person.

So, I would tell my 'friend' that I don't accept anything supernatural, nothing that can't be falsified/verified/replicated.

3

I think you are right to let him go there on his own if he wants too. I was once PM'ing on an atheist forums with a very personable and bright English Christian who had a wife and young kid, mostly answering his questions and reassuring him I had no judgment against him on account of his religious stance. As a result he decided he didn't believe any longer. But his enthusiasm was short lived and soon he became miserable and depressed, which made me feel badly. I had no desire for him to drop his belief. As a result I am even more careful now when I talk to believers. I much prefer to move them toward better (ie, less fundamentalist) theology than to get them to switch teams.

Tolerance is good. It's where we all should meet. I get along great with christians in my neck of the woods. And vice versa, as far I know

3

I think it is perfectly OK to pose "leading" questions. Like, "In Science a questioning critical mind is encouraged and admired. In religion, it is discouraged in favor of faith and scripture. Why do you think that is?"

3

I would have told him that personal beliefs are "always evolving!" My personal beliefs have evolved over a lifetime... And are still evolving. I don't want to think like someone else nor would I want anyone else to think like me. There are A LOT of people questioning their beliefs during this pandemic... Look for answers you can reconcile as truthful in general and to/for yourself.

3

You did the right thing. Don't push him towards any direction. He needs to come to his own conclusion. Just let him know you are there for him if he wants to talk about it.

3

I think that’s the correct approach. The important factor is that he’s your friend.

3

I would encourage him to do research on the Bible to see if it is less perfect than what the preachers tell him. Then I would offer my own research to show him that the Bible contains false prophecies and contradictions, and ask him to prove me wrong, if he can. 🙂

3

I would let him advance the process. If you try to unconvert him, he's likely to resist. I know for me it was a process. I did it on my own.

2

I think you did the kind patient thing. Christians are overwhelmed by preachers. He doesn't need another preacher. He needs to start to think for himself. Depending on his denomination he may have no experience thinking his own thoughts and owning them.

What you did let him know that you are a safe friend with whom he can sort this delicate process out.

He might have some hard days ahead and you want any conversations you have with him to be calm and reasonable dialogues.

What you did was really neat.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:496789
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.