Agnostic.com

37 6

How good are you at striking up conversation with a stranger? Do you allow your prejudices and assumptions prevent you saying even hello let alone being able to allow others differing opinions or do you simply hubristically block to protect your ego, time, patience or anger?
A recent study comes up with some surprising conclusions:

[curiosity.com]

FrayedBear 9 Sep 18
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

37 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

I do not like to be imposed upon uninvited, nor do I like to impose myself upon others, I find it very bad manners.

After 40+ years of Australia Len you may find that habit dies off a little. ?

You would hate it in California. Lots of friendly people here. Strangers strike up conversations with each other all the time.

@misternatureboy "wow, that was a BIG one!" after an earthquake is not generally viewed as an imposition, right? lol! been there, done that! i rode plenty of buses in california. one of the best conversations i ever had was on a bus with someone who had been a stranger. (strangers don't always remain strangers.) she was a little girl, riding the public bus, alone, to school. she sat down next to me and we talked. one day she started to say something and then she stopped. "what?" i asked.

"oh," she said, sheepishly. "i forgot you weren't a kid. i was just going to tell you some kid stuff."

that was one of the highest compliments i ever received!

funnily enough, her mother and i also used to strike up conversations on the bus, and it took me ages to realize that these two even knew each other, because i never encountered them on the same ride. they lived a couple blocks from me and i never would have met them had i been unwilling to strike up conversations with strangers.

on the other hand, i haven't only done that in california. but i could not help noticing that minnesotans are, or at least were when i first got here, more reserved.

g

@genessa
"she was a little girl, riding the public bus, alone, to school. she sat down next to me and we talked."
Do that in the UK you'd be on the sex offenders register before you could say "Stranger Danger"

@LenHazell53 why? she sat down next to me. i probably said hello or something similarly suspicious.

g

@genessa, @misternatureboy Don't get me wrong, I'll talk to people in social situations, or at places of shared interest, but if I am out alone, I am invariably doing something and so am busy, I don't particularly want to know about you unless you have something interesting to say and I have asked you about it.
If you are a cab driver I'd rather you concentrated on driving instead of telling me who you once had in the back of the cab.
I have a very low bullshit tolerance, even less so for trivialities and small talk.
I know what the weather is like, i am out in it
I know buses are always late
No you don't know me from somewhere or else you would know who I am
No I don't want a Sweet, I am sugar intolerant
I am not interested in someone's Aunt sally who once went to a hospital for a check up and came home with her arm in a cast, and when they removed the cast there was just her fingers and her shoulder and the arm was missing.

@LenHazell53 gee, i usually just tell people if i like something they're wearing. if they look as if they're absorbed in some other activity i leave them alone. i don't just yack for the sake of yacking. is there no in-between for you, no possibility that someone could be friendly without being obnoxious?

g

@genessa Being female you might get away with it, but in the North of England, it is a place where a Paediatrician was once chased out of her home by an angry mob because her title sounded to much like Paedophile.

@LenHazell53 if that were typical, it probably would not have been reported, right?

g

@genessa Again maybe it is local, but English, people, English men especially find it highly suspicious if a stranger talks to you, they are usually either after something, trying to sell you something or trying to distract you while someone else picks your pocket.
I worked in retail for years, friendly strangers who want to chat are usually up to something, or have a partner who is emptying the shelves in to a sack.

@LenHazell53 i've spent quality time in england, struck up conversations with stranger, including shop clerks, and never had a problem, except for one guy who chatted me up to get some money out of me. i found him amusing but he dropped me when he realized i was on to him.

your story reminds me of a poll here that found a certain percentage of participants would kick their kid out of the house if they found out he was a homo sapiens.

g

@genessa Paedophiles tend not to get reported in Teesside, they tend to be found dead in their front rooms and nobody saw nothing.

[dailymail.co.uk]

@genessa lol, yeah I've heard that one before, people that dumb I would rather not talk to

@LenHazell53 you mistake my meaning. i mean the idiots mistaking the person's job for the word for a sexual deviant and chasing her out of her home. that has to be unusual or it would not have been reported.

g

@genessa No I understand, but moral panic sells news papers, about twenty years ago the whole area was embroiled in the biggest child sex abuse case ever and the papers and TV made such a fuss over it that all the rent-a-gob wanna be vigilantes here abouts have been on the hunt ever since.
It turned out in the end it was two local child services doctors who were diagnosing almost every child referred to them as an abuse victim, but by the time this was discovered a culture of caution set in, talking to an unaccompanied child who is not directly related to you or who is not under your guardianship is a big no no especially if you are male. (my first aid instructor even told us not to administer first aid to minors with out first getting permission from a parent and being chaperoned.

It's a mad world.

@LenHazell53 well, a mad portion of it, anyway.

g

@LenHazell53 I would definitely want to hear more about Aunt Sally.
England sounds like a miserable place. I used to live in a country where people kept to themselves a lot and friendliness was perceived with suspicion. Being an extrovert, moving to California was such a breath of fresh air for me.

@MissMac I know, it happened in Portsmouth after particulally savage child murder, but it did happen in Teesside too at the height of the Doctors Marietta Higgs and Geoffrey Wyatt 1987 fiasco, and in then again Gwent where a Podiatrists office was vandalised with the word Pedo spray painted on the door.
It was all preempted by a cartoon in Private Eye magazine four months before which showed a man running from an angry lynch mob screaming "I'm a Paediatrician"
This lead to a mock weekly article
101 things to mistake for a paedophile.

3

i am fabulous at striking up conversations with strangers. i do it whenever possible. my guy is shy and is just amazed how i used to talk to people on buses (i don't ride public buses anymore) or how, at a social gathering, i just start talking to just anyone. i don't make more than than the usual assumptions (like that the other party is alive, if i see breathing and eye movement) or prejudices (i would probably not strike up a conversation with someone wearing a swastika armband).

g

I have an old friend like that. He would and did talk to anyone on the 4 hour daily train commute. None are friends. 25 years in a singles club and I don't think that he has any friends that last more than a few years. He is travelled, intelligent to a point, sensible, football mad and drinks. After 76 years, the last 40 mainly lived without a woman and yet he is still out there in the herd looking for one.

@FrayedBear i'm not friends with anyone i have met on a bus where i currently live, not solely because i no longer ride public transportation. when i lived in los angeles, i made friends on the bus, since we turned out also to be neighbors. but i do not have your friend's problem at any rate. i live with my guy; we've been together for 18 years. i don't drink. (i hate football too.) i've never belonged to a singles club. i always enjoyed being single. now i enjoy being half of a couple. i don't think your friend's trouble stem from his ability to chat easily with strangers. one doesn't do that with the expectation of their becoming friends. one does that to be friendly (which is different) and to make the ride, or the gathering, or whatever, pleasant, and also because chatting with others can be, in and of itself, pleasant.

g

@genessa indubitably and particularly when a 4-hour commute is calling. I'm not sure that my friend, who I haven't seen for ten years but we talk about every 3 months, actually has a problem. He simply makes out that he has a problem.
Long ago I read that historically one third of the population never marry or have children. If still true a fascinating fact.

@FrayedBear i never had children because i didn't, and don't, want them. i never married because when i was young there appeared to be one framework for marriage, which seemed to me to be the equivalent of prostitution, and i wanted no part of it. my relationship with my guy is not like that. we may as well be married, but we're old and sick and poor, and marriage would actually result in our losing the meager benefits that keep us alive. we may get around to it if we survive, but it surely won't be for the purpose of having children.

g

@genessa you make some laudatory points particularly about children, prostitution and elder abuse through discriminatory law.
I have just had a quick read of your profile and it makes the remark above of not talking to swastika-bearing people all the more intriguing. I think that I probably still favour the Pol Pot method of conversation with intellectuals when it comes to swastika wearing people. Thank you for your replies and good luck with the biography

@FrayedBear thank you kindly. i am rewriting a portion of it because alas that portion was begun before i owned a computer that actually had a hard drive. it operated on a system that, if it were a car, would be the equivalent of one with square wheels. it's gone. pffft, gone! meanwhile i've lived more than another third of my then-lifetime, so the is more bio to graph. i might never catch up! (i wonder if that would contribute to literal immortality or only literary immortality?)

g

@genessa I remember the days of 5" and 3.5" floppies and a 40-megabyte hard drive was pure luxury! A friend recently told that Window latest version does not recognise the old drives. How true that is I don't know.

@genessa It all depends if current events are germane to the story and shed new light into your biography.

2

I am always a little timid to approach people at social gatherings if I haven't met them before. Especially if it is an entirely new group of people. As someone who has funky hair and lots of visible tattoos, I seem to make some people uncomfortable. There is one notiable time where I was speaking to a group of my peers about a project I was working on regarding ectoparasites. Someone joined the conversation, and kept cutting me off when ever I would try to answer a question about the subject. They hadn't realized I had brought up the topic, and proceeded to tell me after cutting me off a forth time, that no one cared for the opinion of a young woman with purple hair. They were absolutely not kidding.

Rude.

I hope you told the effing prat you had more right to express yourself as you raised the subject and that the colour of your hair has nothing to do with your opinion. Effing prat!

How old was he?

@FrayedBear I absolutely put the guy in his place. He was probably 50/55. Unfortunately it happens more often than not, but it takes all kinds. There is nothing like being a little different to make middle aged men lose their minds. ?

@VashtaNerada The only problem that I have with purple hair is when it is menapausal purple on some batty middle age woman!

@FrayedBear I will likely have purple hair when I'm menopausal, lol. There is also the distinct possibility it could be blue or red. It is funny though, that purple hair has become to middle aged women, what sports cars are to middle aged men. I'm all for what ever makes your heart happy, as long as people stop being mean lol.

@VashtaNerada lol. Q. What's the difference between a clown and a Menopausal man wearing golfing trousers?
A. The clown knows that he is wearing funny pants.

2

For someone who has social anxiety and who doesn’t like people, I tend to end up talking to total strangers for hours and hours with no problem. I think it’s more crowds I have trouble with.

I end up talking too much. But mostly because I am so nervous. I wish I could just shut up sometimes.

@Ubergooroo I actually enjoy the chats. And we would cover tons of different topics. Before I know it three hours have passed.

@graceylou & @Ubergooroo have you tried Toastmasters. They teach and allow you to practice honing the skills you already have to improve them to high levels of desirability.

@FrayedBear I’m not sure why I would need it since I don’t want to talk to people most of the time. As for public speaking, I’ve taught university classes and given lectures. In high school I competed in public speaking competitions....in French. I don’t have a problem talking to people; I just don’t want to.

@graceylou Sad that you have no desire. You have so much to offer.

@FrayedBear Well, I work with dogs and I talk to them a lot.

I tend to get frustrated with people being idiots. Or being too normal. I would rather not to be around them.

3

I have never had a problem talking to almost anyone.

The boy can shout at the Emperor "you've got no bloody clothes on" take on life? Seemingly these days there are many who simply block you.

@FrayedBear While l find humanity extremely disappointing, l do enjoy talking with individuals. I seem to have a curiosity about people.

@Sticks48 As my bro said "the day that you stop learning is the day that you are dead". He stopped learning 20 years ago this month when he was hit head on whilst riding his motorbike on his birthday weekend by an inexperienced motorcyclist wearing an illegal black masked look good helmet on the wrong side of the road on a blind corner.

@FrayedBear So sorry to hear that. Of all the emotions, grief is by far the worst for me. Everything else pales in comparison.

@Sticks48 Strangely my bro was the only one out of my family that I briefly grieved. We were like cat and dog for nearly 50 years and so had business that will never be accomplished now.
I guess my motto is "live the day and do not grieve if tomorrow does not arrive - just try and make sure that your bucket list with each person is fully ticked off."

@FrayedBear Sounds good to me. ☺

1

I suck at it really. I struggle past the hello most of the time unless I can deduce a similar interest or one of their interests and ask questions about it, etc. I'm pretty bad with small talk, and I don't like it either.

Have you tried Toastmasters?

@FrayedBear Why are you angry? Lol

@Piece2YourPuzzle ?? how do you deduce from my suggestion for you to perhaps have a good time that I'm angry?

@Piece2YourPuzzle Ah my emoji!

@Piece2YourPuzzle Simple. In my world you are responsible for replacing what you do not like with something that you do. The emoji has a second meaning - "disagree".

@FrayedBear I don't "dislike" being bad at it and I don't see it as a problem for me. I dislike small talk, but I don't dislike not being good at it just like I don't dislike being bad at being a bridge builder (no pun intended). It's still my choice anyway.

1

A stranger is a stranger you haven't met.

? Isn't that supposed to be "a stranger is a friend that you haven't made yet"?

? Hello.

@FrayedBear I'm just saying leave strangers alone. Well. I leave strangers alone. I'm not good with new folk.

@weelittleone I find it fascinating however that almost everything I have encountered about you says "I'm me I want to be noticed." You are noticed and that is the first step to moving from stranger to "hey buddy, wanna drink and share your craic". If you don't mind me saying so, you are good at that and that is good enough for me and for you to converse and share more.

@FrayedBear that's nice of you to say. But I might note that this site is a bit artificial regarding meeting strangers. No one has to see what I look like, how my voice sounds, how short I am, that my clothes don't fit well... All that stuff. Over here, our standard is how well we respond over time with our typed out words. IRL I would never join or start the conversations going on here

3

I live in Kansas. It's perfectly normal to strike up a conversation with a total stranger here. Everybody does it.

Even Dorothy ... or did she start the habit?

@FrayedBear I don't know if Dorothy started it or not but you can go to Liberal and chat with the Dorothies, they have several.

@sewchick57 Liberal is a town in USA.

@FrayedBear Yes. Liberal is a small town in Kansas and it's where the Wizard of Oz museum is and they have at least 6 Dorothys every year.

3

I seem to attract people who want to tell me all about their lives. Simple eye contact, a smile, they start taking. So no problem, really.

The dis- or advantage of a patriarchal elder's beard?

@Gwendolyn2018 it's your amazing long hair.

0

after decades in the service industry, I can talk to anyone. Of course that part of me is an entirely false front designed to make people comfortable and relaxed, and not actually representative of who I am.

Does it truly do that or is it like the check out chicks insincere "have a nice day"?

@FrayedBear That doesnt fly when your income is tip based.

@dellik each struts the stage and plays his part. You admit to a false front. The customer accepts that as part of the social contract.
I have never had to work under such crappy conditions and thank you for opening my eyes to the possibilities. At one point I became local union delegate in a national campaign that saw wages in a so-called profession be shamed into coming out of the 1800's. Being a waged employee sometimes, however, has worse implications than being tip based as you are beholden to one person directly responsible for your income. When beholden to many you have the luxury of less damagingly telling the obnoxious to fuck off.

@FrayedBear I have done both through out my career. (served front of house, cooked and ran kitchens back of house.)
It honestly works the other way, (I know, counter intuitive)
If I am good enough at what I do, I can tell a manager (or even owner ) to fuck off and let me work, without any actual repercussions. But no matter how good I am, if I were to say the same to a single customer, as a server, I am going to be unemployed.

But The actual point I was trying to assert is that my 'false front' serves me well in normal social situations as well. as a chronicly antisocial person, if I wish to make people more comfortable/unaware of my own discomfort I can turn on that persona, leaving all but the closest to me unaware of my unease.

3

I talk to everyone, all of the time. My girl and I are the ones walking through target like "I love those shoes" "where'd you get that shirt?" "That smells good, you should get it" "who dey!" "Do you think and 8yo boy would like this or that better?" "Your smile is so pretty!"

This is why the boys won't go shopping with us. But, we meet so many nice people!

@Gwendolyn2018 With that gorgeous hair and slim figure of yours you know that you cannot help but elicit attention from others. But why laughter, yours is not a face that invites others to laugh at it?

1

My dad was in sales before he entered teaching, and he taught me how to engage anyone in sincere conversation, not just shallow talk. But I sometimes choose not to. I am frankly uninterested in talking to anyone in a Make America Great Again hat, for example.

UUNJ Level 8 Sep 19, 2018

You mean that you believe that it once was great?

@FrayedBear This countrynhas always had enormous potential, and it’s beautiful, and there are many caring concerned people. It’s also been run by white men happy with a white supremacy, patriarchal culture, whcih is inherently problematic. And the misplaced idea that it is a Christian country is a problem. So we are not without our issues here. But most countries have issues.

@UUNJ ? my question was partly rhetorical and slightly tongue in cheek.
It was good of you to reply, thank you.... Conversation with a stranger - and some say they don't get stranger than Frayed Bear's. ?

3

Having moved a lot when I was younger I learned to make myself be outgoing. My wife and I just finished up traveling around the United States for 4 years and I thoroughly enjoyed meeting new people at every stop along the way. No matter where we traveled we found that most people have the same hopes and desires.

Desire to dominate the rest of the world and have it as your slaves and providers?

@FrayedBear I think the deilsire you speak of is wished for by only a very few %. Most of us just want to be happy, safe, and be surrounded by friends and family.

Have you watched the news clip from Israel about Israel going to DEFCON3?Israel on Defcon3?

- Agnostic.com [agnostic.com]
4

I am good at talking to strangers. People find me easy to talk to, and frequently overshare. I think I have a broad base of general knowledge and find chit chat easy. After doing that for a while I need to slip back into my solitude and recharge.

That sounds like it came from my own mouth. I think we're related somehow. 🙂

@Anne209 Sistahs from another mother.

3

I can talk about anything to anybody. It's one of the few things I really like about myself even when I'm feeling down.

Hordo Level 6 Sep 18, 2018

Because it lifts you up? Perhaps you should do it more often - make a friend a day.

2

Work as a dj and been in the entertainment and service industry for over 25 yrs.
Can talk to a large crowd no problem but still have problems striking up conversations with strangers.

Missing your security blankets?

2

Nothing surprising about those conclusions.

I do often engage (primarily with theists) for the purpose of exposing the errors of their faith (belief without evidence) position.

When It come to females, I really don't have to worry about rejection because most all around here are theists so there there is virtually nobody I would be interested in. So my position is not dependent on being accepted or rejected as my goal is not to impress them. If they display an extended social interest, I demonstrate in lack of tolerance for religious beliefs and no gain, no loss.

No magic cookie!

1

It depends. When I was working, or with friends, I am fine. If I meet someone when I am out, and there are a lot of people around who all know each other, I am usually pretty quiet.

The person who believes that "it is better to be thought a fool than open your mouth and prove it", is usually just in need of a good dose of self esteem. There is nothing wrong with them.

2

I am not good at all at starting a conversation, but once I get going it's hard to get me to stop?

Proving the research?

1

I work in retail and avoid contact with strangers as much as possible, helps working in the back.

There are many arseholes presenting themselves and their shopping at the checkout. Lol, there are also some "beauties" on the checkout as well!

1

Hello.

I can say hello to everyone.

And "hell" to everyone I love. 🙂

A dumb joke, and not an obvious one. I am trying to say that I am often more crude to the ones I love than strangers. Not a good habit I know.

2

I'm terrible at it because I'm really awkward. I always end up saying stupid shit. So usually I don't even try because I'd rather spare everyone else the embarrassment.

Like I suggested below and got stomped on have you tried Toastmasters? They can be very good at continuing your learning. Practice makes perfect - perhaps you also need to know that the person who doesn't make mistakes and talk shit at some time has not yet been born. I remember my first day behind a broadcasting microphone - it was fortunate that I wasn't wearing shorts otherwise the noise of my knocking knees would have been broadcast throughout the land! ?

3

I'm lucky, because I'm an extroverted Australian living in England. It means I can ignore many of the rather stuffy local conventions, and people don't think I'm mad, just antipodean.

Best of all worlds - apart from the b.cold and wet!

2

I fairly often strike up conversations with strangers and it sometimes surprises me to see how eager most people are to talk. I don't mind saying that I usually stay away from controversial topics like politics or religion (or lack there of). I find that most people seem very happy to engage is some conversation. A small number of people just keep it to a few words, some will want to keep the conversation going and others are happy with a short conversation but almost everybody engages at some level. It is also interesting to see stranger's face's light up and it is clear they appreciate that someone "broke the ice". I think it's great but not a great time to get on a "soap box".

OCJoe Level 6 Sep 19, 2018

We are herd animals.

2

depends most social interactions take place in a pub and nowadays revolve round my rescue dog so he generally carries the brunt of the interactions for me.If they are loud and obnoxious they can fuck off but if just looking for some social discourse sure any red flags during that though eg racism homophobia misogyny etc again they can fuck off but are told so in words not actions

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:182134
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.