Interestingly enough, this is what broke me from organized religion.
I was in the desert in Qatar with a couple of Islamic believers. At the time I considered myself a skeptical Southern Baptist (born and raised, don't you know?) and we got into a discussion about religion.
We agreed that both Islam and Christianity had grown from the same (Abrahamic) roots and discussed the fact that in Islam, Jesus is a prophet, etc...
I asked the question "So, as a believer in Islam, what do you think is going to happen to me, a Christian, when I die?"
One of the guys responded with "oh, you know, it's all ok, same religion .. <stuff>"
His friend butted in and said "no, that's not right. You are going to hell".
At that moment, I came to the full realization that I was dead to religion and religion was dead to me.
My response: "Oh, that's too bad"
We drank more tea, enjoyed the night and headed back to Doha just after sunrise.
First convince me of the following:
It's existence outside of greek mythology or others and it becoming part of the Christian religion by proxy
That I can escape it. I have fallen away from the faith and per scripture I've pretty much committed the unpardonable sin. That's why it took a lot to get me away from the faith.
First I laugh, then I tell them we have god within us. We judge ourselves, and I choose not to go to hell. Yeah, Jesus said we would do greater things than him. He also said to look for the kingdom within. You can't really reason with these people though best to say " interesting point of view" and walk away.
My question is, what's the punishment? If it's hell, my answer is, I hope so, because I want to be far, far away from where you'll end up in the afterlife.
I've laughed a few times when they really get frothy at the mouth. I try my best not to argue though, as they are viewing the world through their own experiences, and I really don't know all they've gone through to come to their current situation.
Ha I suppose you could say to them that if god is perfect and he gave us free will then any mistakes or choices you make in life is on god.if god sends you to hell then it is admitting it's mistake and is not perfect.if god puts you in heaven then you can say there is no justice for evil in the next life so why pray to a god like that. There is also the beneficent and willful god argument other Jesus died for our sins argument. Infact there are so many get out of hell free clauses that you never need fear god's wrath again.